Poll Jumping: Drawing Premature Conclusions from Scanty Data
Frederick Clarkson printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Mon Jun 02, 2008 at 03:03:36 PM EST
Much ink has been spilt over the various moderate and sometimes even progressive trends in the world of evangelicalism. And even while writing about "faith" remains strongly in fashion, I remain of the view, politically speaking, that there is much less in these trends than meets the eye. At least so far.

As much as we may welcome evangelicals young and old who have come to, or who have always shared, concerns that are far wider than those of the litmus tests of the religious right, and reject the conflation of one's views on homosexuality and abortion with Christianity itself -- too many folks have jumped to premature conclusions on these things. And as Chip Berlet reminded us last summer, it is just plain wrong to sacrifice the human and civil rights of women and LGBT people in the pursuit of seemingly available political constituencies.

New York Times reporter Neela Banerjee in an article titled Taking Their Faith, but Not Their Politics, to the People  offers some useful perspective. Berlet's point aside, wishful thinkers and gullible punditocrats may have jumped the gun (or jumped the poll) on whether the changes in attitudes among some conservative evangelicals will affect their voting behavior.

 
About 17 percent of the nation's 55 million adult evangelicals are between the ages of 18 and 29, and many are troubled by the methods of the religious right and its close ties to the Republican Party.

In a January 2007 survey of 1,000 young people for the book "Unchristian," one of its authors, David Kinnaman, president of the Barna Group, which studies Christian trends, found that 47 percent of born-again Christians ages 40 and under believed that "the political efforts of conservative Christians" posed a problem for America.

None of that means younger evangelicals have abandoned the core tenets of their faith, including a belief in the physical resurrection of Jesus and the literal truth of the Bible. They think abortion and homosexuality are sins.

And so far, there is no clear evidence that supporting a broader social agenda has led young evangelicals to defect from the Republican Party in great numbers, as many liberals have predicted.

Liberal evangelicals say the difference in approach and priorities among younger evangelicals signals a shift in their political allegiances, too. Surveys, so far, give a murkier picture.

A report last year by the Pew Research Center for the People and the Press indicated that in 2001, 55 percent of white evangelicals ages 18 to 29 identified themselves as Republican, far more than in the broader population. In 2007, 40 percent did. But a more recent Pew poll only of registered voters found that 60 percent of young white evangelicals identified themselves as Republican or leaning Republican, the same as all white evangelicals.

"This is the most pro-life generation I've seen," said John Mark Reynolds, professor of philosophy at the evangelical Biola University in La Mirada, Calif. "I don't have any evidence that being green is going to trump pro-life issues in the voting booth."

Indeed, as liberals and Democrats drool over the prospects of white evangelicals coming over, evidence is scant that they will do so. More to the point, John McCain is a candidate tailor made for the broader agenda conservative evangelical who favors traditional marriage and is prolife, but is not obsessed. Whatever one may think of the merits of McCain's general views, he is far, far from cookie cutter conservativism on such matters as say, immigration and global warming in particular and the environment in general.

That said, top of the ticket aside, it is shaping up as a good year for liberals and Democrats. And many relative conservatives, religious and otherwise, will no doubt come over out of revulsion over the debacle of the Bush years. But how many will stay, and for how long, are different questions.

But the short term opportunism of some Dems, may not help over the long run. Those who would sacrifice or even downplay core values are unlikely to be trusted by their newfound evangelical friends.

For good reason.




Display:
basd on bogus punditry, we get lost in a tangle of false assumptions and often misguided political responses and initiatives.

I'd like to think that the real emerging trend is one that challenges bogus punditry and poll jumping conclusions as the basis for politcal thinking. But unfortunately, I don't have much evidence for it.

by Frederick Clarkson on Mon Jun 02, 2008 at 05:22:42 PM EST


are of more interest to these 18-29 year old folks, I would think. The typical platform just isn't very relevant to their concerns, and I'd expect them to vote agin' gays and abortion, if nothing else is offered.

The person who realizes that young adults have specific economic worries and priorities, and comes up with some amelioration, is the one that will win their vote. It's a crappy time to be a young graduate, whether of high school or of college.

by NancyP on Mon Jun 02, 2008 at 07:02:44 PM EST



WWW Talk To Action


Baptist Professor Opposes Gay Concentration Camp
When voices of profound conscience rise to the occasion, something changes. If we didn't hear that voice or notice the change, it could be......
By Frederick Clarkson (11 comments)
Books That Should Never Have Been Written
Recently I finished James Robison's book on economics, politics and American history.  I thought to myself that the book should never have been written......
By wilkyjr (4 comments)
HeavenUp: Christian Competitor for Facebook?
There may not be an IPO in its immediate future, but if Chris Burkhart and Wes McKinsey, who both grew up as sons of......
By Bill Berkowitz (0 comments)
Templeton Foundation, Christianity Today, and the Promotion of NAR Prophet Heidi Baker
This is the third article in a series about the May cover story on Heidi Baker in Christianity Today. Heidi Baker is being virtually......
By Rachel Tabachnick (0 comments)
Flame of Love Project: Margaret Poloma and the Templeton Foundation Mainstream the NAR
"I wonder what new doors to evangelism might be opened in sophisticated, tolerant, politically correct America if Christians started expressing their faith by encouraging......
By Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
Resolve To Stop Wasting Time: Congressional Republicans Promote Yet Another Pro-Prayer Statement
Americans don't agree on much, but one thing pretty much everyone can agree on is that Congress is not a very popular institution right......
By Rob Boston (0 comments)
We Can Add New Teachings To The Bible, Says New Apostolic Reformation Leader Peter Wagner
[NAR leaders have ties to major U.S. politicians including Sarah Palin, Rick Perry, and Newt Gingrich and have led politicized prayer events attended by......
By Bruce Wilson (11 comments)
How Big of a Liar is David Barton? You Ain't Even Gonna Believe This One!
A couple weeks ago, many people were introduced to Christian nationalist pseudo-historian David Barton when Jon Stewart had him on The Daily Show to......
By Chris Rodda (5 comments)
Christianity Today Promotes NAR Prophet Heidi Baker
Part Two It was a pivotal moment in American evangelicalism when Christianity Today featured a New Apostolic leader on its May cover.  More shocking......
By Rachel Tabachnick (1 comment)
The Barton Lies: New Book Exposes `Christian Nation' Advocate's Long List Of Distortions
Last month I wrote about Religious Right pseudo-historian David Barton's new book The Jefferson Lies, which attempts to prove that Thomas Jefferson was an......
By Rob Boston (7 comments)
Christianity Today Should Retract or Correct Cover Article on New Apostolic Leader Heidi Baker
The cover story of the May issue of Christianity Today features Heidi Baker, a significant leader in the "apostolic and prophetic" movement or......
By Rachel Tabachnick (5 comments)
Quietly Dramatic Developments in the War on Women
Amidst all the noise, there are some quietly dramatic developments unfolding in Washington, DC that may change the course of the battle over access......
By Frederick Clarkson (1 comment)
Fighting the Wrong Battle in North Carolina
As North Carolina voters prepare to vote on an amendment that would constitutionally prohibit recognition of same-sex marriages (along with civil unions and domestic......
By Arlene Stein (1 comment)
Capitol Circus: Religious Right Leaders Plan D.C. Prayer Rally For `Evil' America
On May 8, a group called Come Pray With Me plans to hold a prayer service in Statuary Hall at the U.S. Capitol. This......
By Rob Boston (7 comments)
Pseudo-Historian David Barton's New Jefferson Book is a Load of Crap -- and a Bestseller
Anyone who saw Jon Stewart's interview of Christian nationalist pseudo-historian David Barton on The Daily Show last night probably noticed something missing -- there......
By Chris Rodda (16 comments)

CBS' "Go-to Catholic guy" Steps Down, Admits Fathering Out-of-Wedlock Child
A powerful, cultic religious order whose founder and clergy are accused of sexually abusing minors; admissions of children born out of wedlock... As is often the case, Talk To Action articles written years ago......
Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
Wagner & Rushdoony
In his 2008 book Dominion! - How Kingdom Action Can Change The World, C. Peter Wagner advocated burning books and artwork in the manner of Girolamo Savonarola and traced his movement's dominion theology through......
Bruce Wilson (5 comments)
Jim DeMint to speak at Oak Initiative event
One of the more prominent leaders in the New Apostolic Reformation is holding a conference in June--with a United States Senator as one of the keynote speakers.   Rick Joyner of Morningstar Ministries is......
Christian Dem in NC (0 comments)
Transcript of 1992 John Hagee anti-United Nations/Environmentalism Sermon
This is a transcript of a sermon on a cassette tape I own, titled "Capital Punishment/Environmentalist Agenda/New World Order", that was given by San Antonio Cornerstone Church pastor and Christians United For Israel head......
Bruce Wilson (2 comments)
The Tale of Two Colsons
The tale of two Colsons, one immersed in sin and one redeemed, is the mainstream press's favorite way of approaching the life of Chuck Colson, who died last Saturday. One needs to stress that......
JSanford (0 comments)
Richard Land under investigation for plagiarism
For almost a quarter century, Richard Land has been one of the most prominent voices of the religious right.  But now, the president of the Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission......
Christian Dem in NC (1 comment)
Bryan Fischer, tax protester
Earlier today, American Family Association policy chief Bryan Fischer pretty much shredded whatever pretense he has of being mainstream--or at least what passes for mainstream on the religious right.  On today's edition of Focal......
Christian Dem in NC (1 comment)
Agree to disagree
This entry is in reply to a comment (or a string of comments) under the Bill Berkowitz's article Kirk Cameron's Christian Revisionist Growing Pains. ......
dscribner (6 comments)
Harry Jackson calls for Christians to form "fifth column"
Harry Jackson, the New Apostolic Reformation "apostle" leading the effort to roll back gay marriage in DC, published a revealing column in Charisma magazine.  He argued that in order to launch a second......
Christian Dem in NC (8 comments)
KONY 2012 video blocked for copyright violations?
Invisible Children's KONY 2012 video, viewed over 80 million times, now appears to be blocked on Youtube, accompanied by an attached message that says, "This video contains content from DigiSay Limited and Scripps Local......
Bruce Wilson (2 comments)
CBN told people to go to a minister first if they suspect child abuse
From at least 1996 until this past week, CBN had a teaching paper on its Website that suggested that if you're a victim of child abuse and molestation, you could feel guilty about......
Christian Dem in NC (5 comments)
CBN takes down paper saying child abuse victims can "consent" to being abused
Just confirmed--that horrible teaching paper has indeed been taken down. It's only a start, though--CBN needs to issue a full apology for putting this out for so long. Keep calling, keep the pressure on.......
Christian Dem in NC (4 comments)
How do we open the eyes of folks on the Religious Right?
Having come from a background in the Religious Right, I have a lot of friends who still hold to that worldview.  I want to educate them, but I'm not always sure of what to......
dscribner (47 comments)
So, This Is Godly American Exceptionalism: David Bartons Long Term Plan To Remake America
He was, he says in a letter of May 15, 1817, often "tempted to think that this would be the best of all possible worlds if there were no religion in it."– President John......
AlBratt (0 comments)
So, This Is Godly American Exceptionalism?
"I Like Your Christ. I Do Not Like Your Christians. They Are Unlike Your Christ.–Gandhi"**************David Barton’s Long Term Plan To Remake AmericaDavid Barton’s Long Term Plan To Remake AmericaBy Kyle Maytyla, RWW, 3-16-12"Back in......
AlBratt (0 comments)

More Diaries...




All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments, posts, stories, and all other content are owned by the authors. Everything else © 2005 Talk to Action, LLC. Powered by Scoop