Donate to or support
Talk to Action






Talk To Action Speakers Bureau


Religious Right Organizations

Site Sections

The War on Reproductive Rights

Attacking Public Education

Shadow War: the battle for mainstream faith
the covert campaign against liberal chuches and the social justice tradition

War on Judicial Independence

Recommended Books
[above: click on image for YouTube video trailer]"Renewal or Ruin": New Video Documentary By Steve D. Martin Spotlights Secretive Rightwing Effort To Destroy Mainstream Protestant Churches


Eternal Hostility: The Struggle Between Theocracy and Democracy, by Frederick Clarkson


Right-Wing Populism in America: Too Close for Comfort
by Chip Berlet and Matthew N. Lyons
sample chapter

God's Profits: Faith, Fraud and the Republican Crusade For Values Voters
By Sarah Posner


Liars for Jesus: The Religious Right's Alternate Version of American History
By Chris Rodda


Kingdom Coming: The Rise of Christian Nationalism
: by Michelle Goldberg


With God on Their Side: How Christian Fundamentalists Trampled Science, Policy, and Democracy in George W. Bush's White House.
by Esther Kaplan


Straight to Jesus: Sexual and Christian Conversions in the Ex-Gay Movement
Tanya Erzen


Special Features

Attack on The United Churches of Christ

Attack on The United Methodist Church

"The Christian Right, Dominionism, and Theocracy", by Chip Berlet

Parts OneTwoThreeFourFive

"Taking Over The Republican Party", a four part series by Joan Bokaer

The Woman in A Mink CoatWhile We Were sleepingAngels On a PinheadUnder Cover of Night

The Indian River Incident : What You Can Do

link > The "Stop the ACLU Coalition" Shaming Project
How you can help stop "Stop The ACLU" just by sending a few emails



'Left Behind' video game imageThe Shaming Project

does the violence of "Left Behind: Eternal Forces" bother you ? If so, what can you do ? Well, to begin with you can email Jonathan Hutson's stories to people you know. That will help to bring more public scrutiny of the game. Public shaming really works ! Just click on the "email" icon and link at the top or bottom of the story and you'll be taken to a form that will allow you email the first story, The Purpose Driven Life Takers or the latest installment without leaving this site. Thanks. 'Left Behind' video game image

Donate to or support
Talk to Action




Is Humanism Arrogant?
By TMurray Tue Apr 14, 2009 at 06:53:39 AM EST printable version print story
Much to the dismay of theocratic Christians, humanists claim that ethics can be understood without resorting to the supernatural or alleged divine authority from religious texts.  Christian theocrats say this is hubris.

Many allegedly "humble" Christians claim that anyone who does not believe that God's wisdom is superior to man's is "arrogant". This inverts the actual situation! Anyone who says that God is all wise must mean either (A) that God is wise because anything God does is wise, or (B) that God is wise because God does wise things. If we accept (A) then anything would be wise simply by virtue of the fact that God does it. So, if God arbitrarily tortures human infants, this is wise. If God says 2 + 2 = 3, this would have to be wise too, since God said it. On the other hand, if God is wise because God does wise things (as in B) then this implies that there is some standard by which we can judge which things are wise, and that this standard is independent of God. It is precisely because God conforms to this independent standard that we can congratulate Him on his wisdom. But then God is redundant, since we already know what is wise anyway, and He just happens to get it right.  

In conclusion, one would have to know at least as much as God, if not more, in order to pay Him this "compliment" on His wisdom.  



To discuss this story, sign up for a free account

Display:
Is Humanism Arrogant? | 10 comments (10 topical, 0 hidden)
Hmmm.... (none / 0)
I would ask them:  "Who is more arrogant- someone who quietly helps a disabled person try to function in spite of their physical limitations, or someone who thinks that they can dictate the life of that same disabled person- including (wrongly) judging that the disability is not real?"

That has been my experience- and the more theocratic, the more likely they will fit my experience.  Those "Christians" think they have God's Own Command to pass (false) judgment on others and to tell people they "Know God's plan for your life!!" (said plan turns out to be injustice, misery, and suffering) - and let me tell you- 99.99% of them won't lift a finger to help someone get around a problem- THEY CONDEMN THE PERSON FOR HAVING THE PROBLEM IN THE FIRST PLACE.

(Have you ever heard them say: "If you hadn't ___ [fill in the blank with been drinking, used drugs, spent money on something, SINNED, you name it], you wouldn't be in this situation in the first place!"?  Never mind said situation might have been caused by someone else doing what they shouldn't have and harming the first person.  I've known people whose health and life were ruined by a drunk driver- yet they also got this cr**!  I also have met people who were homeless and got this in their face!)

Atheists, humanists, and liberals on the other hand (in my experience), instead of giving someone a handout that has many hidden strings attached (including condemnation for being in a hard place)- they LISTEN, they quietly try to help, and they CARE.  For the most part, this has been true of about 95% of the atheists/humanists/liberals I've met.

I would then ask them who is more Christ-like and who is more arrogant.

Oh... and this is the corker.  Morality and ethics are culturally defined.  Their so-called "God's standards" are what their culture has taught them.  That is why those "Christians" are also so judgmental towards other cultures.  They confuse their culture with God.

by ArchaeoBob on Tue Apr 14, 2009 at 10:56:45 AM EST

I with you on this one. (none / 0)
Just look to that hideously funny TV ad decrying same-sex marriage. One of the last lines is how these people come together "in love" while they fight tooth and nail to oppress a minority. I'd be left scratching my head on that one if it wasn't just par for the course with the religious right. Moderate Christians and atheists alike should be up in arms in protest to the religious right's usurpation of the faith. I can't think of anything I'd have to complain about re: Christianity, if it wasn't tied to the hip with the radicals who have taken over the conversation for the religious side. Were I a Christian, I'd be plenty pissed about that.

by trog69 on Fri Apr 17, 2009 at 11:46:47 PM EST
[ Parent ]
I am pissed to the point (none / 0)
that it is affecting my enjoyment of life. The woman known as the big Christian where I work volunteered to serve ice cream at the poorest school in the city. These children won this for some academic achievement (of the whole class). All of the children were African American or Hispanic. When we got back the "church lady" told me she wasn't going there anymore because "they just don't appreciate anything". Gee, how does a 6 year old child show appreciation for the free ice cream (we did not pay for it) that they got when she handed them a bowl. And they are so poor that ice cream is a great reward. Honestly, evangelicals are just giving Christ a bad name. I now say... I'm a Christian.... Presbyterian... USA... we have gay people in our church... our published position on abortion is that it is an intensely personal decision and the woman, if she asks, deserves our support and help as she decides....  our pastor went to Harvard. That about does it I think.

by stcrispian on Mon Jul 20, 2009 at 09:10:20 PM EST
[ Parent ]



Evangelical Ethics (none / 0)
Are you suggesting that only one of the options in Euthyphro's dilemma represents the ethical theory of "theocrats?" And how do humanists "understand" ethics?

by SarahFlashing on Fri May 01, 2009 at 02:33:09 PM EST
To answer your questions (none / 0)
I am suggesting that the theocrats have to answer the dilemma, and a dilemma presents two options, both of which are undesirable/have undesirable consequences for their position.  

Humanists understand (why the scare quotes?) ethics as derived from human beings, or from facts about human nature.  That is not to automatically commit the naturalistic fallacy.  One can understand that facts ought to be RELEVANT to ethics without seeing them as IDENTICAL to ethics or as dictating what we make of those facts. Ethics will always be a value judgement about what is important, or most important for human beings, ... or for being 'human'. The problem with theocrats is that they tend to abdicate all responsibility and pretend that they themselves are not making any such judgments about emphasis.    

by TMurray on Mon May 25, 2009 at 04:09:12 AM EST
[ Parent ]



It isn't the god, it is the people who make it (none / 0)
Too many Christians seem to forget the parable of their creation and how Adam and Eve got their bare butts booted from their Eden. Eating the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good & evil (one of the attributes of JHVH) settled that for us. The other tree was of immortality. (Something we could create for ourselves in the future.) So It must be the arrogance of people making godly decisions for their own lives that is inherently both insulting and egotistical to the Christian who abdicates that sin. "Playing god" is something we do every time we don't pray for knowledge for a decision in our lives. If we could all be humanists first we could do many good things to and for each other. No religion need be involved but is okay as long as it helps another. But then we run the risk of us being 'helped' by those who would do us harm like the Inquisition who believed the soul was more important than the corruptible body.

by Nightgaunt on Tue May 19, 2009 at 01:42:19 PM EST
The status of the 'soul' ... (none / 0)
Thanks for your comments.  I agree with you.  I think, though, that the Inquisition represented not a preference for the 'soul' over the body, but a view of human nature as corrupted or dominated by the sinful flesh, in such a way that extrinsic authority was necessary.  Theocrats have always been repelled by the idea that the soul might be able to overpower the flesh and control it - because this would mean that human individuals have self-control and free will, and consequently can be trusted with self-determination.  What started with St. Paul and continued with Augustine was a deterministic picture of human nature controlled by carnal nature, such that the only hope for human goodness must lie in external authorities.  This way, human salvation could be achieved only by OBEDIENCE to these extrinsic sources of "goodness".  If you allow that human individuals  are capable of autonomy, you create democratic forms of government.  Conservatism and authoritarianism rest of a low estimation of human nature and on the belief that humans do not possess genuine free will.  

by TMurray on Mon May 25, 2009 at 04:20:11 AM EST
[ Parent ]


RE: (none / 0)
It is precisely because God conforms to this independent standard that we can congratulate Him on his wisdom.
Online fire science degree | International business education

by Nannes on Mon Jun 22, 2009 at 02:29:10 AM EST

RE: (none / 0)
I've known people whose health and life were ruined by a drunk driver- yet they also got this cr**!  I also have met people who were homeless and got this in their face!)
Accredited degree | Online college degrees | Life experience degrees

by Nannes on Mon Jun 22, 2009 at 02:30:04 AM EST

I'd have to ask... compared to what? (none / 0)
We have a United States Senator, who talked his finely educated and accomplished wife, into dropping everything, submitting to his every will, bearing four children (who have to listen, endlessly to his talk of his mistress) who look to the same sex parent for the most guidance, and have to live in public with his creepy goings on. Then we find that he visits the C Street House in Washington, where men go to be told they are God, and therefore above any moral code or law. I would have to say God created arrogance and for some reason decided to leave it with the Governor of South Carolina.

by stcrispian on Mon Jul 20, 2009 at 08:51:16 PM EST

Is Humanism Arrogant? | 10 comments (10 topical, 0 hidden)

WWW Talk To Action


I'll Die Another Day
As many of you know, I am now recovering at home after two weeks in the hospital and some harrowing experiences. I am feeling......
By Frederick Clarkson (8 comments)
What Palin's "Jewish people will be flocking to Israel" statement really means
There's some acceptance that statements such as Sarah Palin's prediction that Jews will soon be "flocking to Israel" may indicate Palin holds apocalyptic beliefs.......
By Bruce Wilson (3 comments)
Render Unto Caesar: District Tax Officials End Free Ride For Religious Right's `C Street House'
Remember all the talk last summer about the mysterious "C Street house" in Washington, D.C.? The structure, owned by a clandestine evangelical Christian organization......
By Rob Boston (0 comments)
The Africa Connection to the Attack on the Mainline Churches
Three years ago, in an essay in The Public Eye magazine, I outlined how the neoconservative and Religious Right campaign to divide and conquer......
By Frederick Clarkson (2 comments)
Prevaricating Pastors: Mendacious Ministers Prove It's Still Legal To Be Bigots
It's no secret that I'm not a fan of the Religious Right. Through my work at Americans United, I've opposed this movement for 22......
By Rob Boston (2 comments)
Palin's Prayer Leader Hinted Terrorist Attack Could Make Sarah President
In the final weeks of the 2008 presidential election, one of the religious leaders closest to Sarah Palin hinted that the Alaska governor might......
By Bruce Wilson (7 comments)
Hagee, Rodriguez Embrace Signals Massive New Alignments On Christian Right
As JTA News has just reported, John Hagee's Christians United For Israel (CUFI), which represents many millions of American Christian Zionist evangelicals, has formed......
By Bruce Wilson (2 comments)
Archbishop Dolan Disparages Reform and Dissent As "Anti-Catholicism"
In posting on his blog site, recently installed Archbishop for the Diocese of New York, Timothy Dolan, accused The New York Times of anti-Catholicism.......
By Frank Cocozzelli (5 comments)
Bart Stupak, Family 'Minister', Wrapped in C Street Like a Bug in a Rug
Even while protesting that he isn't trying to kill health care reform, House Representative Bart Stupak (D-Mich), who has incurred the wrath of the......
By Bruce Wilson (2 comments)
Unhealthy Trend: House Action On Abortion Showcases Power Of Bishops' Lobby
When political pundits talk about the power of religious groups to affect public policy in Washington, most tend to focus on the Religious Right.......
By Rob Boston (1 comment)
Author of Ugandan Anti-Homosexuality Bill and the "College of Prayer International"
The Uganda New Vision reports the latest on David Bahati, the MP behind the proposed draconian "Anti-Homosexuality Bill"; he was among attendees at a......
By Richard Bartholomew (3 comments)
Rick Warren Repudiates Martin Ssempa
From Warren Throckmorton's blog: STATEMENT FROM PASTOR RICK & KAY WARREN REGARDING ACTIVITIES OF MARTIN SSEMPA IN UGANDA Martin Ssempa does not represent me,......
By Richard Bartholomew (2 comments)
Dobson And Destiny: Will Religious Right Leader Turn His Focus To Electioneering?
James Dobson, founder of Focus on the Family (FOF), is not a happy camper these days.  "What is happening in Washington right now is......
By Rob Boston (5 comments)
Resource Page on John Hagee and Christian Zionism
Special Focus:  Christian Zionism Following are a list of articles on Christian Zionism that have been posted on Talk2action.org over a period of several......
By Bruce Wilson (1 comment)
Progressive Catholics in Maine Push Back on Question One
On Tuesday November 3rd, voters in Maine can either vote yes or no on "Question One," a potential people's veto of recently enacted legislation......
By Frank Cocozzelli (7 comments)

Mark Silk on the Hagee / Rodriguez Entente
Mark Silk, at Spiritual Politics has picked up on my notice of the Hagee-Rodriguez embrace and zeroes in on what's certainly one of the most notable aspects: "The key thing to understand about the......
By Bruce Wilson (1 comment)
Inscribing Christian Values in our Children Before Birth?
Following the evolution of evangelical discourse as it re-defines homosexuality as evidence of "fallen creation", Terri Murray looks at how the Christian right have shifted their rhetoric to adapt to empirical research showing that......
By TMurray (0 comments)
US News & World Report Showcases Creationist Ray Comfort
US News and World Report's Dan Gilgoff has charitably provided evangelist Ray Comfort a media platform in the form of a US News & World "exclusive" through which Comfort defends his efforts to distribute,......
By Bruce Wilson (0 comments)
Atheist billboard in Central Florida
The organization "Atheists of Florida" sponsored a billboard promoting atheism in Lakeland, Florida.  I, however, have some concerns. ......
By ArchaeoBob (2 comments)
Transcript: Billy Graham and Richard Nixon, February 21, 1973
The following is my own transcript of a 20 minute phone conversation between Richard Nixon and Billy Graham, on February 23, 1973. As far as I am aware this is the only publicly available,......
By Bruce Wilson (0 comments)
Rifqa Bary being sent back to Ohio now
Well, there's a change in this case.  After the judge gets immigration documents and so on from the parents, he will send her back. ......
By ArchaeoBob (0 comments)
The War on The War on Christmas Goes To Pot
The first day of Fall could be considered the official launch date for the annual war on the war on Christmas, which represents a significant part of the the American Family Association business model......
By Bruce Wilson (1 comment)
School Officials off the hook
Today it is reported that the judge excused the school officials who violated the agreement they had over separation of Church and State. ......
By ArchaeoBob (0 comments)
Dominionists trying to outlaw birth control
Well, they're at it again in Florida. ......
By ArchaeoBob (2 comments)
No Danger for Rifqa Bary
The FDLE just completed an investigation and found "no credible reports of threats" against Rifqa Bary. ......
By ArchaeoBob (1 comment)
Truth hitting the mainstream!
I've despaired of ever seeing anything critical or exposing Dominionism hit the mainstream press.  There is now an exception. ......
By ArchaeoBob (0 comments)
Extremism?
The term extremism is currently in vogue to describe hate groups and other malcontents listed as such by knowledgeable monitors like SPLC and others in the T2A sidebar, but while we all know what......
By Jay Taber (2 comments)
My Netroots Nation Panel Talk
Where Do We Stand in the Bright Light of History? Netroots Nation August 14, 2009 Thank You, Professor Ledewitz, for initiating this discussion of a progressive vision for church and state -- and Netroots......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
Transcript, Jan. 18, 2009 Steven Anderson Sermon Excerpt
Note: the sermon excerpt video and transcript below, from a January 18, 2009 sermon by pastor Steven Anderson of the Tempe, Arizona Independent Baptist Church, begins at approximately 21:30 into Anderson's  one hour, four......
By Bruce Wilson (0 comments)
More anti-Muslim provocation
The local paper reports that students in Gainsville, Florida are wearing T-shirts with "ISLAM IS OF THE DEVIL" printed on them. ......
By ArchaeoBob (1 comment)
Rifqa Bary to stay in Florida
The young ex-Muslim girl who ran away from her parents will be allowed to stay in Florida.  The news article has strong indications that this is purely political. ......
By ArchaeoBob (10 comments)
Framing Fascism
In her recent article, Sara Robinson argues the United States is well on its way to becoming a totalitarian, fascist state. As evidence of this inevitability, she cites current town hall disruptions and threats......
By Jay Taber (11 comments)
Rock Paper Scissors
GOP-sponsored vigilantism has happened before. It is an integral part of domestic terrorism aimed at ethnic minorities and other sub-populations targeted by White Nationalism and Christian Fundamentalism. Catholics, Jews, Blacks, and Native Americans have......
By Jay Taber (3 comments)
PA Shooter's Church taught: "You can commit mass murder, then still go to heaven"
George Sodini, the 48-year-old misogynist who shot up a Pennsylvania Gym full of women on Aug. 4th, killing three women before turning the gun on himself, believed God wouldn't judge him by his actions.......
By Stacey Tallitsch (0 comments)
Vatican grilling Catholic sisters
While I am not Catholic, I accidentally ran across this article which is of interest to us on this blog - it involves Vatican actions that concern attempts at political control... ......
By ArchaeoBob (3 comments)
Sect Controls Women's Destinies
by Carolyn Jessop and Laura Palmer On The Issues Magazine Had I not escaped one night five years ago with my eight children from the manipulation and control of the FLDS (Fundamentalist Church of......
By On The Issues Magazine (4 comments)
The Religion of Fear
<h2> Living on Guard</h2> In The Religion of Fear, Jason C. Bivins examines conservative evangelical culture as it intersects with America's love affair with spectacular violence and the popular culture of fright that has......
By Jay Taber (2 comments)
Monvee: Profiles of the Mega-churched.
[ed: updated from diary section] Over the last 20 years, a consolidation from the small protestant church has given way to the "Mega-church" where community fellowship goes to die, and prosperity-gospel-rock-concerts are born. Just......
By Stacey Tallitsch (12 comments)
Woman Shoots ex-Husband in Groin, To "Let The Demons Out"
An investigating detective read an entry from a three ring binder, written shortly before the crime: "I know now what I have to do. There are three demonic spirits in (Dr. Loher), one assigned......
By Bruce Wilson (0 comments)
Separation of Church and State attacked in Florida
A Central Florida organization, "The Community Issues Council" has funded a number of billboards attacking the separation of Church and State, using "Quotes" from some of the Founding Fathers. ......
By ArchaeoBob (5 comments)
Radio host: We're only united through Christianity
Most of you in Indiana may know about Peter Heck, who hosts a daily radio show in Kokomo and puts out a column that appears in several newspapers across the state and in OneNewsNow.......
By Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Cindy Jacobs--the new leader of the NAR
You may remember that Lou Engle has made moves of late to position himself as the new power in the religious right.  He's a member of the Apostolic Council of Prophetic Elders, a group......
By Christian Dem in NC (3 comments)
James F. Linzey Espouses anti-Semitic, White Racialist Conspiracy Theory
James F. Linzey is a prominent, active duty chaplain in the United States military. Linzey has stated that he was the command chaplain for the Operation Iraqi Freedom troop mobilization prior to the US......
By Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
White Supremacist named as Holocaust Museum Shooter
An 89 year old, vehemently antiSemitic  Ron Paul supporter has been named by police as the gunman who opened fire in the Holocaust Museum shortly after noon today: Gunman, guard shot at Holocaust museum......
By CynthiaGee (0 comments)
From Focus On The Family to La Familia Michoacana
I didn't think my work on the religous right would converge with what I'm doing on the narcoguerra in Mexico...but here it is: the Faith-Based Cartel. ......
By julydogs (2 comments)

More Diaries...


Donate to or support
Talk to Action
Left Behind: Eternal Forces: Installments of Jonathan Hutson's Talk To Action expose series on the "Left Behind: Eternal Forces" video game have been viewed by up to 1/2 million people. See our site section featuring Over 35 original articles covering the controversial "Left Behind: Eternal Forces" video game that has provoked a boycott by a coalition of religious groups and a letter writing campaign urging Walmart to stop selling the game. Media inquiries click here
(image: detail from Francoise Dubois' rendition of the Bartholomew's Day Massacre reveals the actual nature of religious warfare)







Blogs

Bartholomew's Notes On ReligionChip BerletMax BlumenthalThe Panda's ThumbFrederick Clarkson Chuck Currie DefCon father Jake Stops The World John Gorenfeld Religion Clause Chris Mooney Religious Right Watch The Revealer Jesus Politics Majority Report Radio Blog Mainstream Baptist Orcinus Dispatches from the Culture Wars Ex-Gay Watch The Wall of Separation Blog From The Capital:a blog on religious liberty issues and the separation of church and state

CrossLeft: Organizing The Christian Left Dark Christianity The Daily Kos Booman TribuneePluribus Media My Left Wing Political Cortex Street Prophets

Organizations

American Booksellers Foundation for Freedom of ExpressionACLUAnti-Defamation LeagueAmerican Library AssociationChristian Alliance for ProgressCitizens ProjectDefCon: Campaign to Defend The ConstitutionFaithful America People For the American wayInstitute For Democracy StudiesInterfaith AllianceJews On First: Defending the First AmendmentAmerican Fundamentalists Americans United for Separation of Church and StateBaptist Joint Committee on Religious Liberty The Clergy and laity Network Political Research Associates Theocracy Watch Media Matters for AmericaMilitary Religious Freedom FoundationMontana Human Rights NetworkNational Center For Science EducationReligious Coalition for Reproductive ChoiceThe RevealerSouthern Poverty Law CenterTexas Freedom NetworkCrossLeft: Organizing the Christian LeftTheocracy WatchTruth Wins Out"