Whale Tale: AFA Staffer Says Bible Mandates Death For SeaWorld Orca
Rob Boston printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Thu Mar 04, 2010 at 12:52:53 PM EST
On Feb. 24, a tragedy occurred at SeaWorld in Orlando, Fla. A six-ton killer whale known as Tillikum pulled trainer Dawn Brancheau underwater to her death in front of a crowd of horrified spectators watching a show.

Brancheau's tragic death has led to some soul searching: What should be done with Tillikum? Is it ever appropriate to keep killer whales (also known as orcas) in captivity? Is it right to expect these animals to perform for our amusement?

Relatively few people are wondering what the Bible says about the matter. Luckily, the American Family Association (AFA), the Rev. Donald Wildmon's Tupelo, Miss.-based Religious Right outfit, is on the case.

Bryan Fischer, the AFA's director of issue analysis for government and public policy, is seriously arguing on a blog that the Bible mandates that Tillikum be put to death.

Fischer noted that Tillikum had killed another trainer at a Canadian aquarium in 1991 and a man who jumped into the whale's enclosure at SeaWorld in 1999. The whale should have been killed in 1991, Fischer wrote, because the Book of Exodus requires the execution of any animal that kills a human being.

"If the counsel of the Judeo-Christian tradition had been followed, Tillikum would have been put out of everyone's misery back in 1991 and would not have had the opportunity to claim two more human lives," Fischer wrote.

Fischer cites Exodus 21:28, which states, "If an ox gores a man or a woman to death, the ox shall surely be stoned and its flesh shall not be eaten; but the owner of the ox shall go unpunished."  

 "So, your animal kills somebody, your moral responsibility is to put that animal to death," Fischer insisted. "You have no moral culpability in the death, because you didn't know the animal was going to go postal on somebody."

Furthermore, Fischer opines, because Tillikum killed more than once, his owner is now culpable and can be executed as well.

When a friend sent me this column a few days ago, I thought it might be a satire or maybe the work of someone trying to embarrass the AFA. Perhaps some hackers had broken into the AFA's Web site and posted this. It's that kooky. The AFA is extreme - but this extreme?

So I called Fischer to ask. He called me back promptly to confirm that he wrote the piece and it's not intended as satire. He was cheerful and said he appreciated my checking.

I guess I shouldn't be surprised. Fischer is quite extreme. I heard him speak last fall at the Family Research Council's "Values Voter Summit." He explained to the crowd that Adolf Hitler came up with the separation of church and state and opined that states and local governments don't have to abide by the First Amendment.

Fischer's column has more than a whiff of Christian Reconstructionism about it. Reconstructionists, you might recall, insist that every jot and tittle of Old Testament law be binding on modern society. Thus, gay people, fornicators, those who worship "false gods" or anyone who engages in "witchcraft" (among other things) would merit the death penalty.

Sometimes people ask me why we get so worked up about the Religious Right here at Americans United. Fischer's column, as daft as it is, is a good answer to that question. Here's a guy who wants to kill (by stoning, yet!) a 12,000-pound whale that he believes is guilty of murder - all because of a blind adherence to his fundamentalist reading of the Bible.

If this is the fate that awaits Tillikum in AFA's vision of a perfect society, what do you think is going to happen to you the next time you offend "biblical law"?




Display:
Rev. Wildmon might want to consider the unintended consequences of Biblical literalism: if Tillikum is to be killed by stoning, seems to me Rev. Wildmon would have to be standing close enough to the animal to hit it with a suitably large rock. So lets see, a 12,000 pound killer whale vs. a 200 pound man with a large rock? Based on immediate, past experience, my money is on Tillikum. I say this with no disrespect to the late Ms. Brancheau, who literally put her life on the line to give us "civilized" suburbanites a brief look at a powerful but endangered animal. Forgive me for wishing for more people like Ms. Brancheau, and fewer like the Rev. Wild.mon

by markjandrews on Fri Mar 05, 2010 at 01:33:13 PM EST

I find myself in the odd position of sort of agreeing in a broad way, with the AFA. Not based on the Bible, but just out of respect for human life; I understand that this is the 3rd person that this Orca has killed. If that is right, then how many more people will die before it is put down?

I say turn it loose and if it dies, it dies. It will die anyway eventually, and it would only add to the tragedy if it kills another person.

by COinMS on Sat Mar 06, 2010 at 08:53:40 AM EST

This Orca has killed -- and I would suggest that a motive of self-defense should be considered in some of the cases. And certainly human error was involved. The Orca was taken from its natural habitat, confined in much smaller spaces, deprived of its natural community, and put through its paces in a manner which, for all we know, it might have felt as we would feel torture. If it were to be released back to its natural habitat, respect and honor would require that be done with care and such assistance as it needed to return safely -- not just dumped to live or die. In any case, the conditions of its imprisonment, and that of others of its kind, merits reconsideration, particularly in light of the possibility that it is more sentient than it has been given credit for. Those who work with Orca -- and similar species -- are on notice to treat them with caution and respect.

by Khalila RedBird on Sat Mar 06, 2010 at 07:07:02 PM EST
[ Parent ]


Down Rob, boy! Down! You may not like the concept but there are laws on the book which may well give cause to either demand release or outright order the destruction by death of the killer whale.  

Sever damages might also be awarded under the circumstances you report.  

I suggest you review the below website and other related sources of legal information.

The Vet tells me to toss you two bones and make sure you get a good night's rest, Rob.  That's a good boy.  Down ! Down! That's all right.  Good boy ... good boy!

Most sincerely, Avrahaum

http://www.dogbitelaw.com/

by avrahaum on Thu Mar 04, 2010 at 05:05:32 PM EST

As someone who's spent some time in the wild with the beasts (courtesy of Dave Neiwert, who turned me onto kayaking with them), I need to make two points strongly. (I'm even putting them in boldface.)

1. There is no record of a human being ever being killed by an orca in the wild.

2. Keeping orcas in captivity makes them crazy.

This poor critter has been pushed to the limit by his experience in captivity, and is making his anguish clear in no uncertain terms. No, I am not anthropomorphizing: Orcas, along with their dolphin kindred, are quite possibly the second most intelligent animals on earth after us. They are capable of not only language, but dialects within a language; they are tool-using; and they recognize broad and complex kinship ties (aunts, uncles, cousins, grandparents) within their pods.

Putting an animal like this in a small, isolated pool for life is the equivalent of putting a human in a tiny solitary confinement cell and leaving them there forever. We are not at all surprised when years of that make people crazy and aggressive; but for some reason, we're stunned that this particular orca is fighting back the only way he can -- and seems likely to keep fighting back until we get the point.

Given how extremely endangered orcas are, destroying him when there are other options would be a crime against the species and the few remaining ecosystems that sustain them. On the other hand, there's also the possibility that he could bring this behavior home to the wild and teach it to others, putting an end to the long detente between people and orcas. (They're social enough that this is possible.) His handlers are facing a tough choice -- but they need to make it, and soon.

Whatever they decide, keeping him is not an option.

by Mrs Robinson on Sun Mar 07, 2010 at 02:24:36 PM EST
[ Parent ]



Whale Tale: AFA Staffer Says Bible Mandates Death For SeaWorld Orca
Ray Of Hope With Acai
Acai: The remedial plan of the future


by HomeBusiness11 on Mon Mar 08, 2010 at 08:25:13 AM EST


WWW Talk To Action


Satan's Candidates
According to Christian Right leader Lou Engle, evangelical Christians who don't get political are helping elect Satan's candidates. In an interview with Charisma magazine,......
By Frederick Clarkson (1 comment)
Message to U.S. Airmen: "Accelerate Your Christian Journey"
The Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) receives a constant stream of photographs from service members and DoD employees around the globe showing overt promotions......
By Chris Rodda (34 comments)
Gay-Bashing Emerging as Core Christian Right Election Strategy
Keep your eyes on the Christian Right’s 2010 Values Voter Summit in two weeks in Washington, DC. http://www.valuesvotersummit.org. The main title for the event......
By Chip Berlet (3 comments)
Beck's Dreck: Fox News Host's Real Target Is Religious Liberty
Now that Glenn Beck's Lincoln Memorial rally is over, it's time to step back and ask the all-important question: What the heck was that......
By Rob Boston (1 comment)
Note to Dems: Run Against the Koch Brothers.
If we want to beat Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin and the Astroturf phenomena that is the Tea Party movement, why not go for the......
By Frank Cocozzelli (8 comments)
King & Beck: Tracing the Trajectories
Trace the trajectory of Rev. King from his "Letter from Birmingham Jail" (April 16, 1963) to his speech at the Washington Mall (August 28,......
By Chip Berlet (12 comments)
When Politics Means the End of the World (as we know it)
The Christian Right has often sought to stay the hand of God, angry with our failings as a nation, by `standing in the gap'......
By Frederick Clarkson (3 comments)
No, Alveda King, Our Founders Did Not Put "God" On Our Money
Much has been written in recent days about Martin Luther King, Jr.'s niece, Dr. Alveda King, because of her hooking up with Glenn Beck......
By Chris Rodda (2 comments)
Mainstream Media Falls For "Hitler May Have Had Jewish and African Roots" Hoax
Is it the hoax of the year ? Well, time will tell but so far an embarrassing number of mainstream media venues (see list......
By Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
The Jewish Daily Forward and JTA Publish a Discredited Anti-Jewish Conspiracy Theory
An article in today's Jewish Daily Forward ends with the statement, "Hitler's father, Alois, is believed to be the illegitimate child of a maid......
By Rachel Tabachnick (0 comments)
Embryonic Stem Cell Funding Blocked by Religious Right
Those  who believe the Religious Right is on its last legs might want to read the newspaper once in awhile. The August 23, 2010......
By Frank Cocozzelli (1 comment)
Ken Starr Praises JFK in Second Baptist Sermon
Ken Starr, the point man who spent $54 million trying to bring down Bill Clinton from the Monica Lewinski affair, preached a sermon Aug.......
By wilkyjr (2 comments)
Short Takes - Religious Right Pre-Election Rallies and Training
It's challenging to keep track of all the national events the Religious Right has planned in preparation for the upcoming election.  To be held......
By Rachel Tabachnick (2 comments)
U.S. Soldiers Punished For Not Attending Christian Concert
[editor - Talk To Action contributor Chris Rodda is Head Researcher for the Military Religious Freedom Foundation, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that combats illegal and......
By Chris Rodda (47 comments)
Beyond Toleration: The Enduring Message Of Washington's Letter To The Touro Synagogue
President George Washington received an interesting letter 220 years ago today. Washington was visiting Newport, R.I., and Moses Seixas, an official at the Touro......
By Rob Boston (0 comments)

Glenn Beck, Alveda King - and Reproductive Rights
We are delighted to welcome Rev. Carlton Veazey's return as as a guest front pager. He is the longtime President and CEO of the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice. -- FC The exclusionary values......
Reverend Carlton Veazey (0 comments)
Rival protests held at Ground Zero Islamic centre site
Hundreds of people took part in rival protests over plans for an Islamic centre near Ground Zero in New York. Police kept the banner-waving groups apart, although there were no reports of violence between......
Erica Lewis (1 comment)
Women Challenge Gender Apartheid in the Catholic Church
by Angela Bonavoglia from On The Issues Magazine If ever there were doubt about the relationship between the Catholic Church's spectacular failure to address the clerical child sex abuse crisis and the church's glaring......
On The Issues Magazine (1 comment)
Upcoming counter-protests against recent anti-mosque protests
Recently here on Talk to Action, Rachel Tabachnick mentioned an anti-Islam "Ground Zero Mosque Rally" to be held on Saturday, September 11 by the so-called "Freedom Defense Initiative" and "Stop Islamization of America."  This......
Diane Vera (0 comments)
A Response to Gay Gene Eugenics
In recent weeks the American broadsheets announced that a prenatal pill used to treat congenital adrenal hyperplasia could have the side effect of reducing the likelihood that females treated with the drug will be......
TMurray (0 comments)
Straight Man's Burden
September Harper's has a remarkable article by Jeff Sharlet - not yet available online. ......
daerie (1 comment)
From John Hagee's Can America Survive: Ten Prophetic Signs That We Are The Terminal Generation
Following are a few quotes from John Hagee's latest book, released June, 2010.  Also see the Media Matters post on the book and excerpts at Simon Schuster's website. ......
Rachel Tabachnick (0 comments)
Why is it worth $70 million to ordain 58 men?
The Archdiocese of Denver recently ordained five new priests bringing the total to 58 men commissioned to serve in Northern Colorado who had been trained in its two seminaries. Based upon the 2000 through......
bettyclermont (0 comments)
Nationally Famous Dog-Beating Moralist Offers Advice On Raising Girls
Nationally known Focus on the Family founder James Dobson has a new book out with advice on raising girls, Bringing Up Girls. Over the past several decades, Dobson has become a trusted authority on......
Bruce Wilson (3 comments)
Documents related to atheist lawsuit
Here is a link through the local paper to some of the documents connected with the lawsuit by the Atheists of Florida against the city of Lakeland, Florida. ......
ArchaeoBob (1 comment)
Who Do You Blame For The Holocaust ?
Who was really responsible for the Holocaust ? It's a question people have been asking since before Milton Meyer's 1950's landmark book, featuring post-WW2 interviews with average Nazi Party members, They Thought They Were......
Bruce Wilson (1 comment)
Rampaging Atheist Horde Targets Christianity, Warns "Biblical Dinosaur" Expert Ken Ham
As Young Earth Creationist impresario Ken Ham wrote in a July 6th post on his Answers in Genesis web site, "Recently, atheists met at a conference in Copenhagen and released what they call their......
Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
Texas again
Radical conservatives are launching an attack on Texas higher education by way of a so called "transparency law" in Texas colleges and universities. ......
cloyd (3 comments)
Churches trying to get Oil Money
This news article states that some churches are already seeking money from BP because of the oil spill, and others are considering it.   ......
ArchaeoBob (0 comments)
Bad news in Florida
Florida has done it again.  The legislature passed a law that went into effect today protecting the "right to public prayers". ......
ArchaeoBob (0 comments)

More Diaries...




All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments, posts, stories, and all other content are owned by the authors. Everything else © 2005 Talk to Action, LLC. Powered by Scoop