Islam, Religious Violence, "Brainwashing," and Countersubversion
Chip Berlet printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Fri Mar 11, 2011 at 10:22:45 AM EST
The hearing on Islamic radicalization staged by Rep. Peter King is an appalling example of the media being sucker-punched.

Where in the recent news coverage were interviews with social scientists who actually study how religious ideology can intersect with violence and terrorism? Let's start with some basics.

People do not become religious fundamentalists because they have been "brainwashed," coerced, or are mentally unstable. They become involved in social movement mobilization and recruitment built around themes of religious obligation.

Most religious fundamentalists are not violent.

There is no direct causal relationship linking religious fundamentalism and violence.

When religious fundamentalists use violence or terrorism, the single most significant common factor is a sense of humiliation. As Jessica Stern, an actual expert on religion and terrrorism, explains:

"...one of the primary tasks of a religious terrorist leader is to capitalize on some feeling of humiliation, often related to identity, that they find in potential members. It could be a personal feeling of humiliation, or it could be civilizational, national. They make their followers feel that the way to forge a new identity is by getting involved with this violent group." [More Here]
There should be serious hearings on the potential for terrorism in our society and how to protect our nation without tossing the Bill of Rights into the shredder. Actual experts should give testimony. Experts like Jessica Stern, author of Terror in the Name of God: Why Religious Militants Kill.

Instead we have the Lieberman hearings where ideologically-biased testimony is presented at hearings led by a smart and cynical hypocrite who uses his stage for political gain.

And we have the King hearings led by a witch-hunter so ignorant and bigoted that he probably would have lost a game of tic tac toe against Joe McCarthy.

Over at the National Catholic Reporter is an excellent article on the link between the King and McCarthy hearings by Michael Sean Winters [More Here]

The theoretical linkage is a concept called "countersubversion," which is a fancy name for a political or religious witch hunt. As readers at Talk to Action know, this is one of my pet areas of research.

Historian David Brion Davis noted that movements to counter the "threat of conspiratorial subversion acquired new meaning in a nation born in revolution and based on the sovereignty of the people," and that in the US," crusades against subversion have never been the monopoly of a single social class or ideology, but have been readily appropriated by highly diverse groups."

Frank Donner. a historian and civil libetiers attorney, perceived an institutionalized culture of countersubversion in the United States "marked by a distinct pathology: conspiracy theory, moralism, nativism, and suppressiveness." This countersubversion hysteria is linked to government attempts to disrupt and crush dissident social movements in the United States.

Donner suggeted that conspiracists in the government and private sector periodically create a "countersubversive" apparatus as a response to dissent.

The FBI's counterintelligence program of illegally spying on and disrupting dissidents from the 1950s to the 1970s, dubbed COINTELPRO, is an example of an operational conspiracy ironically based on a conspiracist worldview that suspected widespread subversion by leftists.

Davis points out that:

"genuine conspiracies have seldom been as dangerous or as powerful as have movements of countersubversion. The exposer of conspiracies necessarily adopts a victimized, self-righteous tone which masks his own meaner interests as well as his share of responsibility for a given conflict.

Accusations of conspiracy conceal or justify one's own provocative acts and thus contribute to individual or national self-deception. Still worse, they lead to overreactions, particularly to degrees of suppressive violence which normally would not be tolerated."

How long before the mainstream media repudiates this new witch hunt?



Display:
Religious fundamentalists can be quite violent, but it's an in-group thing.  They use violence to keep the members in line.

Sometimes that violence is physical.   Most of the time it is mental or emotional (or social), and I can argue that these forms of violence are real and can be just as devastating as physical violence.  

They also use fear and humiliation to keep people in line, and those are in a sense forms of violence.  

I think the distinction between fundamentalists and terrorists needs to be between in-group and outside-group violence.  Also, this would explain why fundamentalist groups can become terrorist, because if their violent tendencies are directed outward (as well as inward), they will commit terrorism.

Maybe we could say that there is a spectrum here, from the barely fundamentalist clear to the most violent terrorist.  Now, at the same time there seem to be common elements that are found in fundamentalist groups, and other elements (such as the humiliation or perception of humiliation you described) that seem to be more connected to terrorism.  This would fit right into the spectrum concept too.

Many Muslims don't even begin to fall into the fundamentalist category, and thus the whole worldview pushed by King is completely wrong.  Someone also needs to inform him that Christianity has just as much a terrorism problem as Islam, and the problem is the common elements found on the fundamentalist-to-terrorist spectrum.

One of those common elements is hatred and fear of the Other.  Another is the perception of group superiority and Other inferiority.  Many of these characteristics have been mentioned before.

by ArchaeoBob on Fri Mar 11, 2011 at 01:55:37 PM EST

I see ArchaeoBob's comments as an expansion on Chip's post; I don't see a disagreement necessarily between the post and comment. Chip states that most fundamentalists are not violent. ArchaeoBob states that when there is violence there are degrees of it, and it can be directed in-group or towards outsiders.

Perhaps instead or in addition to the idea of a spectrum running from fundamentalist to terrorist would be an axis graph showing the points where where fundamentalist beliefs and use of terrorism connect. For instance, some of the most extreme forms of fundamentalist Christianity are not equally the most likely to embrace terrorism; these forms may include a withdrawal from society, nearly the opposite of terrorism.

by IseFire on Fri Mar 11, 2011 at 05:00:44 PM EST
Parent

The operational connection is totalist control through intense psychological coercion.

Here is an exchange from Facebook:

Janja Lalich: Chip, You may not like the word "brainwashing," but you can't deny that some people are strongly influenced by the people around them in those social movements, who help "convince them" (dare I say, psychologically coerced?) to engage in violence. I'm not for a witch hunt, either -- but we shouldn't overlook the powerful social psychological mechanisms that sway individuals toward acts of extremism that they may not have otherwise participated in. It takes more than ideology.

- - -

Chip Berlet: Hi Janja. You know I respect your work, and I accept your criticism as constructive. I should have explained more about my frustration about how the term brainwashing was being used to suggest the average Mosque engages in it, when that is... not true.

Do I think that some small groups within Islam qualify as totalitarian and use high demand coercive psychological techniques to bind a recruit to the new identity? Yes. And we both certainly agree that such manipulative techniques are powerful in the totalist groups we have both studied.

My point is that if some member of Congress scheduled hearings about how coercive psychological techniques can be used to promote religious violence (in Islam, Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism, etc,), or political violence, and invited you or any of a dozen actual experts on totalist formations that both of us could name off the top of our heads--then I would be applauding.

_ _ _

Chip Berlet: Research for Progress - Building Human Rights
by Chip Berlet on Sat Mar 12, 2011 at 01:16:10 AM EST
Parent
I doubt it would happen, because the Pentecostal/Dominionist/Fundamentalist churches wouldn't stand for being examined.

This raises the whole separation of church and state issue.   By singling out Muslims, the jackass is violating that.

Cultural pressures and issues are also important in the discussion.  Many of the things the Religious Right is ranting about concerning Muslims are actually based on local cultures and not on Islam.  The power of culture on individuals is generally misunderstood and taken too lightly.


by ArchaeoBob on Sat Mar 12, 2011 at 07:47:37 AM EST
Parent

I work with fundamentalists across several religions who agree with me.  So please paint with a finer brush.
_ _ _

Chip Berlet: Research for Progress - Building Human Rights
by Chip Berlet on Sat Mar 12, 2011 at 10:41:57 AM EST
Parent
Chip, I've read testimonies and life stories from walkaways who not only left dominionism, but from fundamentalist groups of all descriptions including ones that are considered rather peaceful (exception being Muslim - I've only known a few Muslims including a couple that are colleagues.)  Coercion is ALWAYS a characteristic of fundamentalist groups (so much so that I consider it part of the definition).  They may not show that coercion (and the mental/emotional violence) to outsiders, but the people who escape them always have similar stories of being pressured and coerced to conform to the group (or at the least face devastating changes and expulsion if they do not).

I rather imagine Muslim fundamentalist groups are similar.  I haven't talked with my colleagues about it.

Deception and putting on a false front are also characteristic of fundamentalist as well as dominionist groups.  They don't want people to see what really goes on inside.

In fact, there are fundamentalist groups (opposed to theocracy) in the US that may be as coercive and tending towards brainwashing and micromanagement of the members as the Assemblies of God or the NAR, strange as that may sound.   The stories of sexual abuse and so on are just as frequent as well.  I've 'talked' with people who walked from the UPC, and the churches they left were absolutely anti-dominionist, but they were still so coercive and abusive that the people who left could barely function.  The church did not want to take over the world or the country - they wanted to be left alone.  Yet they treated their members as badly as some NAR walkaways have reported.

I don't care that much about what they believe, because there is difference in belief within each group, not to mention the differences between the groups within a category (such as the NAR).  What I'm concerned about is how they treat people - both within the group and without.  To me that is what is critical, because I care about their victims.

On this we will have to disagree.  You say I am stereotyping and painting with too broad a brush.  From my perspective you seem to be splitting hairs and ignoring some pretty strong commonalities that I have observed over the years.  

by ArchaeoBob on Sat Mar 12, 2011 at 01:43:48 PM EST
Parent







Chip, I appreciate all of your work on government repression and terrorism issues, but I have to take issue with you claim that "[w]hen religious fundamentalists use violence or terrorism, the single most significant common factor is a sense of humiliation."  This is not the case.  Social scientists Scott Atran and Jeremy Ginges have found that humiliation is a negative predictor of involvement with terrorism, at least amongst Palestinians living in the West Bank and Gaza. (Abstract for their paper is here).  See also Atran's recent book, Talking to the Enemy: Faith, Brotherhood and the (Un)making of Terrorists.

-------------
"I believe in a President whose views on religion are his own private affair" - JFK, Address to the Greater Houston Ministerial Association
by hardindr on Sun Mar 13, 2011 at 05:14:43 PM EST


WWW Talk To Action


Refuting Nullification, Part One
The emerging influence of Thomas J. Woods and other neo-Confederate ideologues within the Catholic Right was the focus of the first post in this......
By Frank Cocozzelli (1 comment)
The Film the Christian Right Does Not Want You to See
The acclaimed documentary God Loves Uganda, which depicts the role of American conservative evangelicals in generating vicious antigay campaigns in Uganda will be screened......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
Reflections One Month after the Boston Marathon Bombing
A month after the Boston Marathon Bombing, the unified response here in the Boston area is the slogan "Boston Strong," which I see on......
By Chip Berlet (0 comments)
The Partisan Preacher's Complaint: Franklin Graham Has No Grounds To Whine About IRS
The ongoing scandal over the Internal Revenue Service's heightened scrutiny of Tea Party groups took another twist yesterday when evangelist Franklin Graham complained that......
By Rob Boston (3 comments)
`Merry Christmas' In May?: Texas Legislators Reaffirm Right To Use Holiday Greeting
Texas legislators appear to have too much time on their hands. Members of the House of Representatives just passed legislation protecting everyone's right to......
By Rob Boston (5 comments)
Why Nullification Matters
In the first post in this series, I discussed the push for secession and nullification now being made by Catholic Right Neo-Confederates, notably Thomas......
By Frank Cocozzelli (5 comments)
Rios Montt, Hero to the Christian Right, Guilty of Genocide in Guatemala
Former Guatemalan dictator and darling of the American Christian Right, Rios Montt, was found guilty of genocide, making world news. ABC News has a......
By Bill Berkowitz (8 comments)
"It's Great to be a Government-Paid Missionary"
These are the exact words of Maj. Douglas W. Duerksen, a military chaplain, which you can hear for yourself in the embedded video below.......
By Rachel Tabachnick (2 comments)
Mark Sanford and His Free Pass from Religion
Mark Sanford, recently elected Congressman from South Carolina, has hit the airwaves with a startling comeback. The former governor of the state, hid in......
By wilkyjr (7 comments)
Christian Right Default: Blame the Jews
This past week we saw a remarkable example of the whipping-up of outrage over the alleged persecution of Christians. The story turned out to......
By Frederick Clarkson (2 comments)
Investigating the Indiana Family Institute
The Indiana Society of Professional Journalists gave Andy Kopsa its 2012 award for Best Investigative Reporting for a newspaper under 40,000 in circulation.  And......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
Thomas E. Woods, Jr. and the Neo-Confederate Catholic Right
Thomas Woods is an increasingly influential  player on the Catholic Right. In this and a subsequent post, we will consider how his world view......
By Frank Cocozzelli (3 comments)
Memo To The Religious Right: You Don't Need The Government To Tell You When To Pray
Thursday is the National Day of Prayer, and if you want to pray, by all means have at it.I'll let you in on a......
By Rob Boston (3 comments)
Book in 2012 Predicted Boston Bombing Motive
A book published in 2012 predicted the motive for the suspects in the Boston Marathon bombing. Terrorist's Creed, by professor Roger Griffin, explains how......
By Chip Berlet (0 comments)
The End of the Literature of Pooh Poohery about Dominionism?
It is no small thing that Sally Quinn, doyenne of religion at The Washington Post, seems to have turned around on the problem of......
By Frederick Clarkson (1 comment)

Christian Hate For Hire
The Chairwoman of Republican Liberty Caucus of Washington (the Ron Paul formation), is Sandi Brendale, wife of Philip Brendale–a featured speaker at the regional Anti-Indian Conference held in Bellingham on April 6. Sandi Brendale,......
Jay Taber (3 comments)
Mississippi high school forces students to attend Christian lectures: lawsuit
Reposted from Raw Story: A high school in central Mississippi allegedly forced students to watch a Christian video and listen to church officials preach about Jesus Christ. The American Humanist Association's legal center filed......
COinMS (0 comments)
PA Candidate Max Myers Advocates Theocratic Church Governance
I'm working on a story to go with this video, but for now here's just the video. For context, see Rachel Tabachnick's story, NAR Leader Running for Governor in Pennsylvania - As a Democrat......
Bruce Wilson (1 comment)
Former Maranatha Pastor Stars as Thomas Jefferson in Fox and Friends Segment
I wasn't planning on playing Seven Degrees of Maranatha Campus Ministries this evening, but was instead perusing my usual array of news and opinion websites when I found this gem on Talking Points Memo:......
ulyankee (5 comments)
American Family Association launching drive to influence 2014 elections
CBN's David Brody has learned that the American Family Association is greasing the wheels for an effort to influence the 2014 elections.  The American Renewal Project, an AFA-affiliated group that helped push Prop 8......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Kevin Swanson encourages Christian educators to break law and push religion on kids
cross-posted at dKos Kevin Swanson of Generations Radio was in rare form on his podcast yesterday.  He decried the numerous Supreme Court decisions that have resulted in government-mandated prayer being barred from the public......
Christian Dem in NC (1 comment)
Far-right religious group behind 'Path to 9/11' film continues to infiltrate mainstream media
‘Path to 9/11’ director David Cunningham, who was outed a few years ago as a member of the far-right group Youth with a Mission, has been toiling away on a number of media projects......
unholyalliances (1 comment)
S. 3526: Military Religious Freedom Act of 2012
My senator, Roger Wicker, has introduced the Military Religious Freedom Act of 2012. A couple of things here: 1.) It's very interesting that it bears the exact same name as the Military Religious Freedom......
COinMS (2 comments)
West Point cadet drops out to protest influence of fundamentalist Christianity
Blake Page was a senior at the United States Military Academy, slated to graduate in May.  He was due to be commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Army, and once he left the......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Brownback endorses major fundie/dominionist prayer rally on Saturday
Those of you in the Kansas City/Topeka area, be on alert--there's going to be a major invasion of fundie lunacy in Topeka on Saturday.  And it has the endorsement of none other than Kansas'......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Why is the religious right defending an unrepentant con man who preyed on minority communities?
All indications are that the religious right is rallying to the defense of Jews Offering Alternatives for Healing (JONAH), the "pray away the gay" outfit that is facing a lawsuit from four former clients......
Christian Dem in NC (1 comment)
Mike Bickle's Sexually Charged "Bridal Mysticism" IHOP Teachings
I've been picking through Mike Bickle's teachings on Bridal Mysticism and the Song of Solomon - which Bickle seems to view as allegorical for the end-time relationship of the church (the Bride of Christ)......
Bruce Wilson (19 comments)
Rick Joyner and Bob Jones delude themselves into thinking Obama will help them
Two days ago, I mentioned that Rick Joyner hosted a post-election "webinar" with another NAR leader, Bob Jones.  In it, Joyner and Jones actually laughed about the damage wrought by Hurricane Sandy because......
Christian Dem in NC (3 comments)
NAR leaders LAUGH about destruction wrought by Hurricane Sandy
If you want to get a picture of how fundamentally sick and twisted the New Apostolic Reformation is at bottom, I offer as an example a video recently released by Rick Joyner. Yesterday, Joyner......
Christian Dem in NC (16 comments)
Rick Joyner, who wants to set up a dictatorship, accuses Obama of wanting to set up tyranny
Last Sunday, Rick Joyner told his flock at MorningStar Fellowship Church in Fort Mill, South Carolina (only 20 minutes south of me--gag) that if Obama is reelected, he plans to set up "the worst,......
Christian Dem in NC (5 comments)

More Diaries...




All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments, posts, stories, and all other content are owned by the authors. Everything else © 2005 Talk to Action, LLC.