Concocted Controversy: Religious Right Complaints About 9/11 Commemoration Ring Hollow
Rob Boston printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Tue Aug 30, 2011 at 12:14:41 PM EST
The 10th anniversary of the 9/11 terrorist attacks is approaching, and for some reason, Religious Right groups have decided to manufacture a new "culture war" controversy over a commemorative event that will take place in New York City.

New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg has decided that the focus of the day should be on the families who lost loved ones during the attacks. He hasn't invited any clergy to speak at the event. Instead, family members will read short passages that are meaningful for them. President Barack Obama, President George W. Bush and some other political leaders will also make brief remarks, but Bloomberg has made it clear that political speeches are not welcome.

Bloomberg's decision to have no official clergy presence at the event doesn't mean there will be no religious activity during the ceremony. In fact, there will be six moments of silence, during which attendees can pray, mediate or reflect as dictated by their individual consciences. A spokesperson for the mayor has also stated that some of the readings by family members will undoubtedly be spiritual in nature.

Because the focus will be on 9/11 families, clergy aren't the only ones who won't be taking part in the event. 9/11 first responders will also not be on the stage, and some of them are unhappy about that.

But again, that doesn't mean these groups won't be recognized. There will be many commemorative events in New York and other cities in and around Sept. 11, 2011. The New York Police Department, for example, has planned an event for Sept. 8 that will include prayers. In addition, an interfaith service to honor first responders is scheduled for Sept. 6.

Yesterday, during an appearance on the web-based FoxNewsLive.com, I debated this issue with Ken Klukowski of the Family Research Council. (A portion of the debate can be seen here.) Klukowski opined that Bloomberg's actions are some sort of affront to religion and an example of radical secularists attempting to purge religion from public life. I reminded him that on Sept. 11, millions of Americans will be praying (if they so choose) even if no clergy are part of a government-sponsored service.

Nevertheless, the Religious Right keeps piling on. Klukowski's FRC is sponsoring a petition to demand that Bloomberg reverse course. So is TV preacher Pat Robertson's American Center for Law and Justice. American Family Association blogger Bryan Fischer asserts, with absolutely no evidence, that Bloomberg barred all clergy because he doesn't want to deal with Muslim clerics. (That's OK with Fischer - he says such prayers should be limited to Christians and Jews anyway.)

It seems unfathomable to the Religious Right that perhaps Bloomberg is telling the truth and that he'd rather focus the remembrance on the families who lost their loved ones during that tragic day. It seems a fitting tribute to me.

This is just another example of Religious Right groups whipping up hysteria over a manufactured controversy. I expect them to do this when they're blasting Obama or trying to raise money and get in the media with phony claims of a "war on Christmas" or whatever. But it's offensive to pull cheap stunts like this over the national trauma that occurred on Sept. 11, 2001.

Have these people no shame?  




Display:
to have another of those prayer events where only THEIR type of "Christian" can pray or speak.

That's what it sounds like to me.  Nice captive audience for preaching-praying.  (Just as they're known to invade funerals and other solemn events, and try to take them over.)


by ArchaeoBob on Tue Aug 30, 2011 at 12:26:48 PM EST


Since the main 9/11 commemorative event will likely attract the most TV cameras, could it be that the exclusion of the clergy is a smokescreen to cover the exclusion of the surviving 9/11 first responders who got sick breathing ground zero air they were told was safe and who have been largely abandoned by the State and whose nationally broadcast emaciated appearance would be a political embarrassment?

http://secure.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/wiki/Health_effects_aris ing_from_the_September_11_attacks

by MIJ6VI on Tue Aug 30, 2011 at 01:40:32 PM EST



WWW Talk To Action


A Talk to Action Anthology on Nullification and Secession
Over the past few months a number of posts have addressed the growing movement advocating the nullification of federal laws and even secession of......
By Frederick Clarkson (1 comment)
Thomas E. Woods, Jr. And the Right to Oppress
In the last several posts we have examined an element of the Catholic Right  comprised of neo-Confederate apologists who openly advocate both the state......
By Frank Cocozzelli (5 comments)
Freedom From Foolishness?: Texas Gov. Misconstrues Religious Liberty
Whenever I hear someone - especially a politician - say that the First Amendment protects freedom of religion, not freedom from religion, I just......
By Rob Boston (9 comments)
What is Christian nationalism?
Author Michelle Goldberg one of the early regular contributors to Talk to Action, posted an announcement and preview of her excellent book, Kingdom Coming......
By Michelle Goldberg (45 comments)
Fresh Religious Supremacism from the Rev. Dr. Albert Mohler
The Rev. Dr. Albert Mohler, the president of Southern Baptist Theological Seminary has fired another salvo in the war of attrition that has been......
By Frederick Clarkson (5 comments)
Bench Press: Atheist Group Wins Right To Display Monument In North Florida County
By the end of the month, the courthouse in Bradford County, Fla., will be home to a large granite bench covered with quotes from......
By Rob Boston (8 comments)
How the Catholic Bishops Outsmarted Washington Voters
Across the U.S., religious healthcare corporations, called "healthcare ministries" by the Catholic Church, are absorbing once secular and independent hospitals. In the process they......
By Valerie Tarico (1 comment)
Sen. Lautenberg's Stand Against David Barton - More Than Just a Stand for Church/State Separation
With a career spanning three decades, Sen. Frank Lautenberg will be remembered by many different people for many different reasons. Upon hearing of his......
By Chris Rodda (0 comments)
Thomas Jefferson's Twilight Reminder About Religious Equality
Last year I was honored to write a story for The Islamic Monthly, a magazine operated by American Muslim writers and scholars.  I see......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
The NeoCon War Against the Mainline Protestant Churches, Continues
The recent smear of prominent Christian journalist Cynthia Astle by a staffer at the nefarious Institute on Religion and Democracy was a stark reminder......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
Refuting Nullification, Part Two
In this series we have been discussing the emerging influence of Thomas E. Woods and other Catholic Right neo-Confederates, who are advocating that states......
By Frank Cocozzelli (2 comments)
How to Respond to a Bully
We are honored to welcome Cynthia B. Astle as a guest front pager. She is project coordinator for United Methodist Insight, where this post......
By CynthiaAstle (1 comment)
Prayer Wars: When It Comes To Religion, The Majority Does Not Rule
As many of you know, the U.S. Supreme Court decided last week that it will hear an appeal of an Americans United case challenging......
By Rob Boston (4 comments)
The Church Child Sex Abuse Scandal Widens and Deepens
In a recent post, I discussed the apparent lack of sufficient seriousness with which the Southern Baptist Convention and the Catholic Bishops still treat......
By Frederick Clarkson (4 comments)
Refuting Nullification, Part One
The emerging influence of Thomas J. Woods and other neo-Confederate ideologues within the Catholic Right was the focus of the first post in this......
By Frank Cocozzelli (1 comment)

Democrats in Mississippi win big
Despite (or perhaps because of) endorsements made by Gov. Phil Bryant (R) and other Republican state officials, voters in Mississippi elected a surprising number of Democrats in several hard fought mayors races. ......
COinMS (0 comments)
Pat Robertson has a sad over PFAW calling him out
cross-posted at dKos Pat Robertson apparently knows that People for the American Way's Right Wing Watch project has frequently made him a target.  And he doesn't like it.   Yesterday, Robertson led off the......
Christian Dem in NC (0 comments)
Christian Hate For Hire
The Chairwoman of Republican Liberty Caucus of Washington (the Ron Paul formation), is Sandi Brendale, wife of Philip Brendale–a featured speaker at the regional Anti-Indian Conference held in Bellingham on April 6. Sandi Brendale,......
Jay Taber (3 comments)
Mississippi high school forces students to attend Christian lectures: lawsuit
Reposted from Raw Story: A high school in central Mississippi allegedly forced students to watch a Christian video and listen to church officials preach about Jesus Christ. The American Humanist Association's legal center filed......
COinMS (0 comments)
PA Candidate Max Myers Advocates Theocratic Church Governance
I'm working on a story to go with this video, but for now here's just the video. For context, see Rachel Tabachnick's story, NAR Leader Running for Governor in Pennsylvania - As a Democrat......
Bruce Wilson (1 comment)
Former Maranatha Pastor Stars as Thomas Jefferson in Fox and Friends Segment
I wasn't planning on playing Seven Degrees of Maranatha Campus Ministries this evening, but was instead perusing my usual array of news and opinion websites when I found this gem on Talking Points Memo:......
ulyankee (5 comments)
American Family Association launching drive to influence 2014 elections
CBN's David Brody has learned that the American Family Association is greasing the wheels for an effort to influence the 2014 elections.  The American Renewal Project, an AFA-affiliated group that helped push Prop 8......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Kevin Swanson encourages Christian educators to break law and push religion on kids
cross-posted at dKos Kevin Swanson of Generations Radio was in rare form on his podcast yesterday.  He decried the numerous Supreme Court decisions that have resulted in government-mandated prayer being barred from the public......
Christian Dem in NC (1 comment)
Far-right religious group behind 'Path to 9/11' film continues to infiltrate mainstream media
‘Path to 9/11’ director David Cunningham, who was outed a few years ago as a member of the far-right group Youth with a Mission, has been toiling away on a number of media projects......
unholyalliances (1 comment)
S. 3526: Military Religious Freedom Act of 2012
My senator, Roger Wicker, has introduced the Military Religious Freedom Act of 2012. A couple of things here: 1.) It's very interesting that it bears the exact same name as the Military Religious Freedom......
COinMS (2 comments)
West Point cadet drops out to protest influence of fundamentalist Christianity
Blake Page was a senior at the United States Military Academy, slated to graduate in May.  He was due to be commissioned as a second lieutenant in the Army, and once he left the......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Brownback endorses major fundie/dominionist prayer rally on Saturday
Those of you in the Kansas City/Topeka area, be on alert--there's going to be a major invasion of fundie lunacy in Topeka on Saturday.  And it has the endorsement of none other than Kansas'......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Why is the religious right defending an unrepentant con man who preyed on minority communities?
All indications are that the religious right is rallying to the defense of Jews Offering Alternatives for Healing (JONAH), the "pray away the gay" outfit that is facing a lawsuit from four former clients......
Christian Dem in NC (1 comment)
Mike Bickle's Sexually Charged "Bridal Mysticism" IHOP Teachings
I've been picking through Mike Bickle's teachings on Bridal Mysticism and the Song of Solomon - which Bickle seems to view as allegorical for the end-time relationship of the church (the Bride of Christ)......
Bruce Wilson (19 comments)
Rick Joyner and Bob Jones delude themselves into thinking Obama will help them
Two days ago, I mentioned that Rick Joyner hosted a post-election "webinar" with another NAR leader, Bob Jones.  In it, Joyner and Jones actually laughed about the damage wrought by Hurricane Sandy because......
Christian Dem in NC (3 comments)

More Diaries...




All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments, posts, stories, and all other content are owned by the authors. Everything else © 2005 Talk to Action, LLC.