On Nullification
John Minehan printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Fri Jun 21, 2013 at 09:23:23 PM EST
At the time his book, Nullification, appeared in 2010, I contacted author Thomas Woods, Jr., Ph.D. about the book.  Woods is as gracious as he is educated and he took the time to answer my questions in detail.  While Dr. Woods is a brilliant man, he is not a practicing lawyer and he did not see how ineffective nullification is as a legal theory.  

Given a Federal judicial system, a system of Federal prosecutors and Federal peace officers (as early as the 1790s including Federal Marshalls and customs officials and now including the FBI, ATF, DEA, SEC, IRS, Treasury and other agencies with enforcement arms) it is (and essentially always has been) impossible for a state to nullify a Federal law in the sense of preventing its enforcement.

Further, while Woods is absolutely correct in saying that an unconstitutional Federal law does NOT constitute the "supreme law of the land" under the Supremacy Clause ("This Constitution,and the Laws of the United States WHICH SHALL BE NADE IN PURSUENCE THEREOF; and all treaties made, or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States, shall be the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the constitution or laws of any state to the contrary notwithstanding." [EMPHASIS added]) nullification would seem to contradict the intent of the Supremacy Clause by allowing the states to unilaterally nullify Federal law, perhaps for reasons of "faction" or for passing advantage.

Indeed, the reason for adopting the Constitution and forming a more powerful Federal government was to increase the utility of the Union, for example, by preventing states from obstructing the flow of commerce from other states or keeping the states from fighting border fights (neither of which was unknown under the Articles in the 1780s), while avoiding the usurpations of Liberty that the Colonists perceived during the 1760s and 1770s under Lord North's government.  To do this, a powerful and centralized, but not totalitarian, Federal Government was required.  Nullification seems to defeat this purpose.

However, the evidence is that nullification was not thought clearly unconstitutional by the Framers.

While it is not set out in the Constitution , neither is it prohibited. Possibly, the Framers believed that the House being elected by the People while the Senate was selected by state legislatures would preclude these issues or that the right to petition the government would resolve these issues. Neither did, but James Madison's support for the nullification of the Alien & Sedition Act by Virginia and Kentucky in 1798 provides evidence that nullification was NOT considered per se unconstitutional, certainly not as an act of protest.

However, as described above, it remained strikingly ineffective in my view as a practicing attorney. It seemed, in the immortal words of Rocket J. Squirrel, "Again?  That trick never works!"

Then I realized that the virtue of nullification lies not in directly changing law but in marshalling consensus and demonstrating resolve.  It does not, it cannot change the law by itself, but heralds the political will to change the law or the state of political power

While the Alien & Sedition Act might have continued to be enforced by US Attorneys in Federal Courts in Virginia and Kentucky in 1798 and 1799, by the election of 1800 the electorate had turned against John Adams and the Federalists.

While President Jackson might have forced South Carolina to back down in the Nullification Crisis of 1832, Congress quickly mitigated the "Tariff of Abominations."

While the Supreme Court forced Wisconsin to back off from its nullification of the Fugitive Slave Law, that act of nullification demonstrated that the states of the north were no longer content to live in  (per Lincoln's phrase) "a house divided."

Nullification, like jury nullification which has tacitly existed in American common  law since Zenger's case in 1733,, is not law but a check on law.  Since it is equitable but lawless, and always runs the risk of anarchy but tends to moot "lawless order," it must be a last resort.  

Louis XIV said that artillery was "The Last argument of Kings."  If so, Jury nullification is the last argument of juries and nullification is the last argument of state legislatures.




Display:
http://www.tomwoods.com/blog/interview-with-a-zombie/

Woods and his opponents talk past each other.  Nullification does not change law (despite what Wood believes); it signals a change in consensus on law that heralds a change in law or political change.

by John Minehan on Fri Jun 21, 2013 at 10:51:36 PM EST


http://www.libertyclassroom.com/nullification/

by John Minehan on Fri Jun 21, 2013 at 11:33:14 PM EST

Some things Woods sees as "Nullification," are not generally seen as being Nullification in the classic sense.  

California essentially legalized (not decriminalized) medical marijuana about ten years ago.  

They didn't nullify Federal criminal law with regards to marijuana, which required the contraband to move in interstate commerce or wire or mail to be used in moving the contraband.  It was entirely possible to have purely intrastate traffic and that was clearly legal in California and did not involve nullifying Federal law on the subject, because that transaction did not implicate those laws.  

Where the contraband moved in interstate commerce, the Bush (and early on, the Obama) Administration continued to prosecute under the Federal statutes.  However, due to Obama Administration Policy, these Federal Laws are no longer enforced in California.  

It isn't strictly Nullification, but it is an example of how Federal law can be changed by a demonstration of an new consensus in an important state.

Also, where states are offered Federal money to opt into a Federal program and turn down the money also isn't nullification per se, but as with the Real ID Act and the 55 MPH coast to coast this kind of state resistance to Federal policies is more common and more successful than most people see initially.  

The demonstrated resistance to setting up the Exchanges and adopting the Medicaid Expansion, probably bodes very badly for PPACA, for that reason.  

by John Minehan on Fri Jun 21, 2013 at 11:48:33 PM EST




But only indirectly. Like when juries refused to convict bootleggers for the crime of making and selling illegal alcohol. Unfortunately the courts have been instructing juries to not ever consider nullification. As in the effects of a law on a particular person. - We are still plagued by the (some) Drug war since 1914 and it still remains. Until it is finally ended we will still see this low order "war" between states and the Federal govt.

by Nightgaunt on Mon Jun 24, 2013 at 04:53:49 PM EST


WWW Talk To Action


Real Religious Liberty is Not Oppression
This is a reposting of an op-ed I recently published at LGBTQ Nation -- FC Real Religious Liberty is not Oppression FREDERICK CLARKSON Senior......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
Houston Mayor Ignites Fervor of Religious Right
The best take on Houston Mayor Annise Parker vs. the churches in her city is the story written by Marv Knox in the Baptist......
By wilkyjr (2 comments)
Four Stories
LGBTQ Nation   In my first bi-weekly column on religious liberty, I discuss how  "Religious liberty is a progressive and liberatory value, over which......
By Frederick Clarkson (2 comments)
Christian Right Voter Mobilization -- The Season Finale
One of the secrets of the success of the Christian Right over the years has been that opponents have taken the movement with insufficient......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
Sins Of Omission: When Religious Right Leaders Speak, The Whole Truth Is Often Left Behind
When an individual doesn't feel like being absolutely truthful, there are a couple of things he or she can do. One is to simply......
By Rob Boston (2 comments)
Bishop Finn Under Vatican Investigation
Bishop Robert Finn, head of the Diocese of Kansas City-St. Joseph, Missouri has long been a symbol of the ongoing institutional intransigence in addressing......
By Frank Cocozzelli (4 comments)
"The $1-Billion-a-Year [Religious] Right-Wing Conspiracy You Haven't Heard Of"
In honor of the 2014 incarnation of the event known as The Gathering, I've given an interview with Jay Michaelson, writing for the Daily......
By Bruce Wilson (5 comments)
(Un)Fantastic Five: A Remembrance Of Values Voter Summits Past
The Religious Right's annual "Values Voter Summit" (VVS) takes place this weekend. Americans United staffers Simon Brown, Sarah Jones and I will be there.......
By Rob Boston (7 comments)
The Christian Right's Voter Mobilization Strategy for 2014
My latest post at Political Research Associates is about how this weekend's Values Voter Summit fits into the Christian Right's wider electoral strategy for......
By Frederick Clarkson (2 comments)
NYT's David Brooks to Speak at Antigay Luncheon of Billionaires Who Fund Racist Preacher
Recently, government-encouraged outbreaks of mob violence against LGBT persons in countries from Uganda to Russia, and draconian new anti-gay legislation in those countries too,......
By Bruce Wilson (2 comments)
D'Souza's Downfall: Religious Right Favorite Sentenced For Campaign Donation Violations
Yesterday conservative commentator Dinesh D'Souza was sentenced to five years of probation and a term of community service for violating federal campaign laws. He......
By Rob Boston (1 comment)
Short Takes -- Taking Action Edition
Banned Books Week is being celebrated this year from Sept. 21-27.  Yes its time for the annual celebration of the Freedom to Read, sponsored......
By Frederick Clarkson (0 comments)
Archbishop Schnurr Throws Cold Water on the Ice Bucket Challenge
The Ice Bucket Challenge has been an outstanding success in raising both awareness and research money needed to find a cure for Amyotrophic lateral......
By Frank Cocozzelli (1 comment)
The Secret Antigay U.S. Money Behind The WCF and the Global Evangelical War on LGBT Rights
[note to readers: this is an excerpt from my first installment in a Twocare.org/Center Against Religious Extremism series that will examine extensive ties -......
By Bruce Wilson (0 comments)
Race as Religion
Reading Edith Beer's book, The Nazi Officer's Wife, I ran across an interesting account of her fake marriage license.  She married a Nazi officer......
By wilkyjr (2 comments)

Deconstructing the Dominionists, Part VI
This is part 6 of a series by guest front pager Mahanoy, originally dated November 15, 2007 which I had to delete and repost for technical reasons. It is referred to in this post,......
Frederick Clarkson (1 comment)
Republican infighting in Mississippi
After a bruising GOP runoff election for U.S. Senator, current MS Senator Thad Cochran has retained his position and will face Travis Childers (Democrat) in the next senate election. The MS GOP is fractured......
COinMS (2 comments)
America's Most Convenient Bank® refuses to serve Christians
Representatives of a well known faith-based charitable organization were refused a New Jersey bank’s notarization service by an atheist employee. After inquiring about the nature of the non-profit organization and the documents requiring......
Jody Lane (3 comments)
John Benefiel takes credit for GOP takeover of Oklahoma
Many of you know that Oklahoma has turned an unrecognizable shade of red in recent years.  Yesterday, one of the leading members of the New Apostolic Reformation all but declared that he was responsible......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
John Benefiel thinks America is under curse because Egyptians dedicated North America to Baal
You may remember that Rick Perry put together his "Response" prayer rallies with the help of a slew of NAR figures.  One of them was John Benefiel, an Oklahoma City-based "apostle."  He heads up......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Mississippi Religious Freedom Restoration Act.
Yes, that's right. We have totally lost our religious freedom in Mississippi and it must be restored by our legislators. ......
COinMS (1 comment)
Bill Gothard accused of harassing women and failing to report child abuse
Surprised no one's mentioned this, but one of the longest-standing leaders of the religious right is in a world of trouble.  Bill Gothard has been active in the fundie movement for over half......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
Eugene Delgaudio may lose his day job as Virginia county supervisor
Surprised no one's noticed this, but one of the nation's most virulent homophobes is in a fight to keep his day job.  Eugene Delgaudio is best known as the head of Public Advocate......
Christian Dem in NC (0 comments)
Starkville Becomes First City in Mississippi to Pass Resolution Recognizing LGBT Residents
This caught me by surprise. I guess times are a changin in Dixieland. ------------------------------------- Cross posted from the HRC blog. Starkville Becomes First City in Mississippi to Pass Resolution Recognizing LGBT Residents January 21,......
COinMS (0 comments)
Robert Knight: Running against evolution could potentially be a winner for the GOP
In one of the starkest instances yet of how far gone the religious right is, one of its leading activists thinks that he's found another potential wedge issue that could drive more people into......
Christian Dem in NC (2 comments)
First Catholic official convicted in child sex abuse scandal has conviction overturned
Last year, Monsignor William Lynn, the Archdiocese of Philadelphia's secretary for clergy, was convicted of reassigning a priest whom he knew had molested a young boy to a parish that had a school attached......
Christian Dem in NC (0 comments)
Quotes From Sarah Palin 'War on Christmas" Book v. Quotes From 1920s Anti-Jewish Propaganda
The point of this comparison is not to cast Sarah Palin as a Nazi. Rather, my intent is to underline uncomfortable similarities between contemporary "war on Christmas" talking points propagated by elements of the......
Bruce Wilson (0 comments)
Francis sets up commission on how to deal with pedophile priests
Late yesterday Pope Francis announced--apparently after some prodding--that he will set up a panel to advise him on how to deal with child abuse by priests. The announcement was a forthright acknowledgment by the......
Christian Dem in NC (0 comments)
John Hagee: Jews will make deal with Antichrist before End Times
When John Hagee opens his mouth, you expect to hear lunacy.  An appearance earlier this month on TBN was no different.  On Friday, People for the American Way stumbled on a special prophecy-focused edition......
Christian Dem in NC (0 comments)
Doug Phillips Resigns From Vision Forum over "Inappropriate Relationship"
Doug Phillips resigned as president of Vision Forum earlier this week, citing an "inappropriate relationship."   Phillips posted an announcement on the Vision Forum website, stating, There has been serious sin in my life......
Rachel Tabachnick (2 comments)

More Diaries...




All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments, posts, stories, and all other content are owned by the authors. Everything else 2005 Talk to Action, LLC.