Fundamentalists and the Military: James Carroll on the Danger of a New Crusade
Rob Boston printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Tue Sep 18, 2007 at 12:46:14 PM EST
James Carroll, author of the best-selling book Constantine's Sword: The Church and the Jews, has strong opinions about the dangers Christian fundamentalism presents not just to the United States but to the world.

Carroll, in a recent interview with Tom Engelhardt of the Nation Institute, talked about his experiences working on a documentary version of the book. Part of that project involved delving into allegations that an evangelical Christian subculture had taken root at the Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs and, by larger extension, across the U.S. military.

Carroll was appalled by what he found.

"In the Pentagon today," he says, "there is active proselytizing by Christian groups that is allowed by the chain of command. When your superior expects you to show up at his prayer breakfast, you may not feel free to say no. It's not at all clear what will happen to your career. He writes your efficiency report. And the next thing you know, you have, in the culture of the Pentagon, more and more active religious outreach."

Continues Carroll, "Imagine, then, a military motivated by an explicit Christian, missionizing impulse at the worst possible moment in our history, because we're confronting an enemy - and yes, we do have an enemy: fringe, fascist, nihilist extremists coming out of the Islamic world - who define the conflict entirely in religious terms. They, too, want to see this as a new `crusade.' That's the language that Osama bin Laden uses. For the United States of America at this moment to allow its military to begin to wear the badges of a religious movement is a disaster!"

A former Roman Catholic priest, Carroll also warns about rising tide of Christian fundamentalism around the world.

"My own conviction is that a crucial twenty-first century problem is going to be Christian fundamentalism," he says. "Its global growth is an unnoticed story in the United States. Africa, Latin America, and parts of Asia are now absolutely on fire with zealous belief in the saving power of Jesus, in the most intolerant of ways. A religious ideology that affirms the salvific power of violence is taking hold. It denigrates people who are not part of the saved community, permitting discrimination, and ultimately violence. Hundreds of millions of people are embracing this kind of Christianity."

While the interview veers into some other areas, such as the war in Iraq, Carroll's warning on the dangers of politicized fundamentalism is well worth heeding. Fundamentalism's main fault, as Carroll points out, is that is often impervious to facts and stubborn. Its adherents admit no new information and insist on looking to their interpretation of religious texts as a sole guide for governance.

The problem is, those ancient books were never intended to fill that role. The Bible may have a lot to say on how to worship God or get to Heaven, but it can be made to speak on issues like stem-cell research, cloning, in vitro fertilization and other modern controversies only through the interpretation of a human agent.

We have no shortage of fundamentalist "guides" who would claim to interpret the text and tell the government how it ought to respond in the "biblically correct" way. Interestingly, what the Bible mandates the government do and what various fundamentalist leaders would have the government do just happen to always be one in the same. (Just a coincidence, I am sure.)

There is a better way, as Carroll remind us: "America is also a secular nation, of course. The separation of church and state was a critical innovation, giving us this special standing as a people. The separation's purpose was to protect the conscientious freedom of every individual by making the state neutral on questions of religious conscience. An absolutely ingenious insight."




Display:
Carroll mentions.

What seems extremely strange to me, as I've pushed the bounds of research into the influence of the fundamentalist (and usually apocalyptic) Christian right in the US military, is that no one has thought to do  much research into the subject before. My working assumption is simply that everyone who actually has been tracking the Christian right as a movement was simply overwhelmed. But, the question of influence the movement might or might not have in the US military seems like a central one to me - central to the health of American democracy.

Some of the programs I've been studying have been growing and developing for years, but no one has - up to now - bothered to study them. Actually, no one outside of the military, in many cases, seems to have even been aware of their existence. The scope of likely constitutional violations I've uncovered is, in certain case, massive.

I was having  a conversation, recently,  with an associate editor of a major distribution magazine who is working on a soon to be released and very ambitious story on the influence of the Christian right in the federal government. He  apologized to me, saying he said he had been highly dubious of my initial take on the spread of apocalyptic religious ideology in the Pentagon. Now, he's convinced - I've demonstrated it, with more on the way.

Carrol's summation is, in my mind, keenly insightful. He sees the outline of the problem. Along with Chris Rodda, I've been fleshing out that outline with facts.

by Bruce Wilson on Tue Sep 18, 2007 at 03:23:44 PM EST


I would love to see Carroll's research notes. This is the EXACT OPPOSITE of my experience with the military, whether active duty or as a contractor who dealt daily with the Pentagon and others (who shall not be named ). There were small groups of Christians present, but I never have witnessed something like this. I really have a problem believing this dude

by BobValerius on Tue Sep 18, 2007 at 05:53:39 PM EST
It would depend on when and where you were in the military.

But for a short example : the Officer's Christian Fellowship, a subsidiary of Bill Bright's Campus Crusade For Christ, has roughly 15,000 members in the US military officer corps on 200 US military bases worldwide. The OCF appears to espouse apocalyptic theology and is fundamentalist.

Another group, "Christian Embassy", proselytizes directly within the Pentagon and under its auspices reportedly some 350 Bible study groups meet regularly. Christian Embassy appear to advocate the position that the US invasion of Iraq was Biblically justified and is fundamentalist, Christian Embassy is also a subsidiary of Campus Crusade For Christ.

Beyond the US military, there are a number of other fundamentalist, apocalyptic Christian ministries that target the US military.  Campus Crusade is far from the only player.

by Bruce Wilson on Tue Sep 18, 2007 at 06:32:34 PM EST
[ Parent ]

I did not see any political machinations, or any mobilization towards any ends other than forming Bible studies (much like any evangelical denomination would), primarily on overseas bases (where English speaking service-members would have a hard time finding fellowship outside of the base chapel arena). They seemed to work pretty well with the chaplain corps in CONUS, too; and, went out of their way not to step on the toes of the on-base chapel programs. Rather they supported them. I saw nothing I am concerned about, even in retrospect. Even at the USAFA, where I was a cadet (76-80) there were other groups, FCA and NAVs, and a certain USAF LTC's fellowship group, that were WAY more aggressive than OCF. Now, if you tell me something changed in the 90s, I can't challenge that, but in the late 70s and 80s (CO, CA, TX, MO, MD, 7th Corps Germany) I saw nothing scary about OCF or its mission.

by SharonB on Wed Sep 19, 2007 at 12:05:49 PM EST
[ Parent ]
I gather that most reports of intrusive evangelizing in the Armed Forces are relatively recent (2000 onwards), and that the AFA is a hotspot but in general the intrusive activity is sporadic. What seems worrisome is that the rhetoric concerning "discrimination" against conservative evangelical chaplains (ie, making them follow the chaplaincy rules) and concerning evangelization of Iraqis is hot, on various large-audience radio programs aimed at the general (non-military) audience.

by NancyP on Wed Sep 19, 2007 at 09:01:49 PM EST
[ Parent ]

And, the OCF now appears to espouse apocalyptic theological views - as is the right of its members too, but the tendency might worry some Americans. Still, such tendencies present no affront to the US Constitution...  

That's all I'll say right now.


by Bruce Wilson on Wed Sep 19, 2007 at 11:32:39 PM EST
[ Parent ]





Growing up attending a fundamentalist church where end time prophecy was rigorously taught, and seeing how certain bible verses were repeatedly used to explain current events and justify military action, it is no surprise that military personnel would find this type of teaching appealing.

by offbeatjim on Wed Sep 19, 2007 at 08:26:57 AM EST


WWW Talk To Action


Bryan Fischer's Confusion
Bryan Fischer is confused about religion & the American Founding.  Fischer is a long time David Barton follower, the likely source of his confusion.......
By Jonathan Rowe (7 comments)
Was Hitler Gay?
Add to the Hitler list his connection to being Gay.  He has been equated with just about every movement and ideology known to......
By wilkyjr (15 comments)
Beck Goes After HuffPost By Showing Off Rally Attendee's Fake Washington Quote T-Shirt
During his first post-Restoring Honor rally show on Monday, Glenn Beck demonstrated the "contempt" of HuffPost by showing his audience some of the photos......
By Chris Rodda (5 comments)
Satan's Candidates
According to Christian Right leader Lou Engle, evangelical Christians who don't get political are helping elect Satan's candidates. In an interview with Charisma magazine,......
By Frederick Clarkson (2 comments)
Message to U.S. Airmen: "Accelerate Your Christian Journey"
The Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) receives a constant stream of photographs from service members and DoD employees around the globe showing overt promotions......
By Chris Rodda (35 comments)
Gay-Bashing Emerging as Core Christian Right Election Strategy
Keep your eyes on the Christian Right’s 2010 Values Voter Summit in two weeks in Washington, DC. http://www.valuesvotersummit.org. The main title for the event......
By Chip Berlet (4 comments)
Beck's Dreck: Fox News Host's Real Target Is Religious Liberty
Now that Glenn Beck's Lincoln Memorial rally is over, it's time to step back and ask the all-important question: What the heck was that......
By Rob Boston (2 comments)
Note to Dems: Run Against the Koch Brothers.
If we want to beat Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin and the Astroturf phenomena that is the Tea Party movement, why not go for the......
By Frank Cocozzelli (8 comments)
King & Beck: Tracing the Trajectories
Trace the trajectory of Rev. King from his "Letter from Birmingham Jail" (April 16, 1963) to his speech at the Washington Mall (August 28,......
By Chip Berlet (12 comments)
When Politics Means the End of the World (as we know it)
The Christian Right has often sought to stay the hand of God, angry with our failings as a nation, by `standing in the gap'......
By Frederick Clarkson (3 comments)
No, Alveda King, Our Founders Did Not Put "God" On Our Money
Much has been written in recent days about Martin Luther King, Jr.'s niece, Dr. Alveda King, because of her hooking up with Glenn Beck......
By Chris Rodda (3 comments)
Mainstream Media Falls For "Hitler May Have Had Jewish and African Roots" Hoax
Is it the hoax of the year ? Well, time will tell but so far an embarrassing number of mainstream media venues (see list......
By Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
The Jewish Daily Forward and JTA Publish a Discredited Anti-Jewish Conspiracy Theory
An article in today's Jewish Daily Forward ends with the statement, "Hitler's father, Alois, is believed to be the illegitimate child of a maid......
By Rachel Tabachnick (0 comments)
Embryonic Stem Cell Funding Blocked by Religious Right
Those  who believe the Religious Right is on its last legs might want to read the newspaper once in awhile. The August 23, 2010......
By Frank Cocozzelli (1 comment)
Ken Starr Praises JFK in Second Baptist Sermon
Ken Starr, the point man who spent $54 million trying to bring down Bill Clinton from the Monica Lewinski affair, preached a sermon Aug.......
By wilkyjr (2 comments)

Glenn Beck, Alveda King - and Reproductive Rights
We are delighted to welcome Rev. Carlton Veazey's return as as a guest front pager. He is the longtime President and CEO of the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice. -- FC The exclusionary values......
Reverend Carlton Veazey (0 comments)
Rival protests held at Ground Zero Islamic centre site
Hundreds of people took part in rival protests over plans for an Islamic centre near Ground Zero in New York. Police kept the banner-waving groups apart, although there were no reports of violence between......
Erica Lewis (1 comment)
Women Challenge Gender Apartheid in the Catholic Church
by Angela Bonavoglia from On The Issues Magazine If ever there were doubt about the relationship between the Catholic Church's spectacular failure to address the clerical child sex abuse crisis and the church's glaring......
On The Issues Magazine (1 comment)
Upcoming counter-protests against recent anti-mosque protests
Recently here on Talk to Action, Rachel Tabachnick mentioned an anti-Islam "Ground Zero Mosque Rally" to be held on Saturday, September 11 by the so-called "Freedom Defense Initiative" and "Stop Islamization of America."  This......
Diane Vera (0 comments)
A Response to Gay Gene Eugenics
In recent weeks the American broadsheets announced that a prenatal pill used to treat congenital adrenal hyperplasia could have the side effect of reducing the likelihood that females treated with the drug will be......
TMurray (0 comments)
Straight Man's Burden
September Harper's has a remarkable article by Jeff Sharlet - not yet available online. ......
daerie (1 comment)
From John Hagee's Can America Survive: Ten Prophetic Signs That We Are The Terminal Generation
Following are a few quotes from John Hagee's latest book, released June, 2010.  Also see the Media Matters post on the book and excerpts at Simon Schuster's website. ......
Rachel Tabachnick (0 comments)
Why is it worth $70 million to ordain 58 men?
The Archdiocese of Denver recently ordained five new priests bringing the total to 58 men commissioned to serve in Northern Colorado who had been trained in its two seminaries. Based upon the 2000 through......
bettyclermont (0 comments)
Nationally Famous Dog-Beating Moralist Offers Advice On Raising Girls
Nationally known Focus on the Family founder James Dobson has a new book out with advice on raising girls, Bringing Up Girls. Over the past several decades, Dobson has become a trusted authority on......
Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
Documents related to atheist lawsuit
Here is a link through the local paper to some of the documents connected with the lawsuit by the Atheists of Florida against the city of Lakeland, Florida. ......
ArchaeoBob (1 comment)
Who Do You Blame For The Holocaust ?
Who was really responsible for the Holocaust ? It's a question people have been asking since before Milton Meyer's 1950's landmark book, featuring post-WW2 interviews with average Nazi Party members, They Thought They Were......
Bruce Wilson (1 comment)
Rampaging Atheist Horde Targets Christianity, Warns "Biblical Dinosaur" Expert Ken Ham
As Young Earth Creationist impresario Ken Ham wrote in a July 6th post on his Answers in Genesis web site, "Recently, atheists met at a conference in Copenhagen and released what they call their......
Bruce Wilson (4 comments)
Texas again
Radical conservatives are launching an attack on Texas higher education by way of a so called "transparency law" in Texas colleges and universities. ......
cloyd (3 comments)
Churches trying to get Oil Money
This news article states that some churches are already seeking money from BP because of the oil spill, and others are considering it.   ......
ArchaeoBob (0 comments)
Bad news in Florida
Florida has done it again.  The legislature passed a law that went into effect today protecting the "right to public prayers". ......
ArchaeoBob (0 comments)

More Diaries...




All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective companies. Comments, posts, stories, and all other content are owned by the authors. Everything else © 2005 Talk to Action, LLC. Powered by Scoop