The Grand Inquisitor of Wisconsin
Frank Cocozzelli printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Sat Mar 28, 2009 at 01:45:27 PM EST
Bishop Robert Morlino of Wisconsin is one of a small group of Catholic Right leaders who is gradually igniting a firestorm that threatens to engulf all of American Catholicism.  By assuming the role of Grand Inquisitor he recklessly suppresses free expression in the name of quelling what he deems to be heresies.  In his distrust of humanity, Bishop Morlino eerily echoes the infamous Dostoyevsky character: this modern-day Inquisitor does not believe that the most of us can handle the choices that Jesus offers in Christian thought let alone those afforded all citizens in a liberal pluralistic democracy such as ours.
As the National Catholic Reporter observed:

Morlino, 62, is the fourth bishop of the Madison diocese. Previously he served as the bishop of the Helena, Mont., diocese, was a priest in the Kalamazoo, Mich., diocese and was once a member of the Jesuit order. He assumed leadership in Madison in August 2003 and within months was creating waves.

After six months he made a controversial statement that he had found in Madison "a high comfort level with virtually no public morality." Some were not pleased with that assessment. After being confronted with what many saw as an unfair generalization he backed off, saying he had misspoken, explaining that he had been speaking in a philosophical sense.

NCR further reported that the Church in Wisconsin is upset by more than mere insults:

Morino has also stirred controversy with statements he has made concerning political issues and for his assessments of politicians, especially those with whom he disagrees.

Just before the November 2006 elections he required every parish in his diocese to hear a personally recorded message condemning capital punishment, gay marriage and embryonic stem-cell research. Dozens of parishioners walked out of Mass or stood with their backs to the altar when the message played. Others welcomed his muscular teaching of Catholic doctrine.

In a letter to priests -- leaked to the press at the time -- he said any signal of disagreement on their part "could have serious consequences."

Before the November election last year Morino singled out House Speak Nancy Pelosi and then vice-presidential candidate Sen. Joseph Biden for not upholding church teachings on abortion.

 The Capital Times of Madison reported that in June 2008 a local fundraising organization was suing the Madison diocese for a breach of contract for services provided. The diocese apparently reneged on payment after it "refused to tell Bishop Robert Morlino which priests complained about him in a survey on the prospects of a planned $70 million capital campaign to build a new cathedral."

And recently Bishop Morlino escalated his efforts to stifle dissent. This past March 12th, he fired Ruth Kolpack from her position as the full-time pastoral associate at St. Thomas the Apostle Catholic Church in Beloit, Wisconsin.

She had refused the bishop's demand that she renounce a six-year-old master's degree thesis (a Divinity Degree, no less, from the Catholic St. Francis Seminary) in which she argued for more gender-inclusive language at Masses and called for the ordination of women.

Here is a sample of the language that Bishop Merlino found so offensive that it must be renounced:

So, is mother a suitable image for God?  For Second Isaiah, it certainly seems to be.    John Schmitt in, "The Motherhood of God and Zion as Mother," concludes his article by saying:  "Zion as mother appears so frequently in Isa 40-66 that this image should be taken as the inspiration for the depiction of God as mother."
 

As well as:

The language used for God affects males and females differently because of the dominance of male images used for God, especially for public prayer.  The implied masculinity of God contributes to the patriarchal notion of the superiority of the male.  It also contributes to an attitude of diminished self-worth for women. ... Whether intentional or not, the consistent use of masculine language for God in public prayer strips women of their full human value.  Masculine God language sends the message to women that men deserve greater respect.

It is such inquisitorial behavior that makes any sensible person worry about what would happen if Bishop Merlino and those like him were able to enforce their dogmatic beliefs with state power.  A man so willing to persecute members of his own religious community would certainly not hesitate to exact swift retribution from those who do not share his religious convictions. The censure of fresh ideas would be threatened not because they might be better, but simple because of their difference. Bishop Morlino, much like Dostoyevsky's Inquisitor, sees shielding the common man from non-orthodoxy as the path to tranquility.

Bishop Morlino unwittingly leads by example in showing us why se