Media and Rightist Distortions about Dominionism: Take the Refresher Quiz!
Frederick Clarkson printable version print page     Bookmark and Share
Sun Feb 21, 2016 at 04:21:33 PM EST
In light of recent discussions about dominionism and Republican presidential candidate Ted Cruz, it seems like a good moment to refresh our memories about the denial campaign of 2011. -- FC

In recent weeks, a variety of mainstream journalists and conservative writers have treated us to a remarkable display of ignorance, incompetence, and outright sleaze -- and various combinations thereof -- regarding dominionism.  I have collected a sampler of quotes from such writing, not to slam all journalists, but to point out that dominionism is, in fact, central to our current political situation,  not fringe as some would have it,and that the tropes promoted by journalists and op-ed columnists, are not much different than those of hack political operatives.  The attacks on Michelle Goldberg and others of us are unfair, unjustified and frankly unconscionable. And we will continue to respond.

It all began with the massive prayer rally that served as Rick Perry's de facto campaign launch a few weeks ago, and the critical magazine coverage that discussed the role of the New Apostolic Reformation and the dominionist movement powering the Perry and Michelle Bachmann presidential campaigns.

Below are ten quotes from ten different writers or television commentators addressing the matter of dominionism. See if you can identify who was responsible for each quote. Ten points for each correct answer.  Answers for each question at the links.

Charlotte Allen, op-ed columnist, Los Angeles Times
Daniel Burke, reporter, Religion News Service
Jack Cafferty, commentator, CNN
Joe Carter, Web Editor, First Things (a neoconservative journal)
Ross Douthat, op-ed columnist, The New York Times
Michael Gerson, op-ed columnist, The Washington Post
John Hawkins, proprietor, Right Wing News blog
Lisa Miller, religion columnist, The Washington Post
Ralph Reed, Christian Right political operative
Michael A. Walsh, columnist, New York Post

Every time a Republican candidate for high office surfaces who is also a dedicated Christian, the left warns in apocalyptic tones that if you vote for him, America will sink into a "theocracy." Long ago these fear-mongers warned us about Ronald Reagan. Then it was George W. Bush, and after that, Sarah Palin. Now it's Michele Bachmann and Rick Perry. Elect Perry or Bachmann, this year's warnings go, and make way for "Jesusland" -- a country in which adulterers will be stoned, creationism taught in the schools and gay people sent to reorientation therapy.

Charlotte Allen
Daniel Burke
Michael Gerson
Ralph Reed

the fear of theocracy has suddenly returned.  Beginning with Ryan Lizza's profile of Bachmann in The New Yorker, a spate of recent articles have linked the Republican presidential candidates to scary-sounding political theologies like "Dominionism" and "Christian Reconstructionism," and used these links to suggest that Christian extremism is once more on the march...  But it's easy to succumb to a paranoid six-degrees-of-separation game, in which the most radical figure in a particular community is always the most important one, or the most extreme passage in a particular writer's work always defines his real-world influence.

Ross Douthat
Michael Gerson
John Hawkins
Lisa Miller

...if you listen to liberal newspapers, you'd think every other GOP presidential contender is a theocratic dominionist even though I've never met a single conservative in my entire life who favors turning the United States into a theocracy.

Charlotte Allen
Joe Carter
John Hawkins
Michael A. Walsh

The notion that Bachmann, Perry or other candidates secretly harbor "dominionist" theology is a conspiracy theory largely confined to university faculty lounges and MSNBC studios.

Joe Carter
Ross Douthat
Ralph Reed
Michael A. Walsh

The Dominionist goal is the imposition of a Christian version of sharia law in which adulterers, homosexuals and perhaps recalcitrant children would be subject to capital punishment. It is enough to spoil the sleep of any New Yorker subscriber. But there is a problem: Dominionism, though possessing cosmic ambitions, is a movement that could fit in a phone booth.


Ross Douthat
Michael Gerson
Lisa Miller
Ralph Reed

This dominionism nonsense is about the stupidiest [sic] trend to come along since Birtherism.... [Michelle]  Goldberg is the equivalent of Jerome "Where's the Birth Certificate?" Corsi. She doesn't really care about the truth, she just wants to frighten some gullible liberals and sell more copies of her book.


Charlotte Allen
Joe Carter
Ross Douthat
Ralph Reed

Evangelicals generally do not want to take over the world. "Dominionism" is the paranoid mot du jour.... Certain journalists use "dominionist" the way some folks on Fox News use the word "sharia." Its strangeness scares people. Without history or context, the word creates a siege mentality in which"we" need to guard against "them."


Daniel Burke
Jack Cafferty
Joe Carter
Lisa Miller

For those of you who haven't heard of this before - and I was one of those, I hadn't heard of it either - stand by, 'cause this stuff is really out there.


Daniel Burke
Jack Cafferty
Michael Gerson
John Hawkins

The article questioned Bachmann's and Rick Perry's "ties" to something called Dominionism. Never heard of it? Me neither,


Charlotte Allen
Jack Cafferty
John Hawkins
Michael A. Walsh

In recent weeks, an arcane and scary-sounding religious term has crept into the lexicon of the 2012 campaign, tripping from the tongue of everyone from MSNBC broadcaster Rachel Maddow to conservative Christian leader Ralph Reed.

Depending on whom you ask, "Dominionism" either signifies a Christian plot for world domination, or the latest liberal bugaboo.


Charlotte Allen
Daniel Burke
Jack Cafferty
Lisa Miller

                   ----------------------------------------------------------- -----------------------
Quite a few corrective responses to all this have already been written, including How We Coined the Term "Dominionism" and  Inside the Christian Right Dominionist Movement That's Undermining Democracy Chip Berlet, Another Senior Journalist Confesses to IgnoranceDeeper Background on Dominionism by Frederick Clarkson;  and Washington Post 'On Faith' Columnist Flawed Article Dismisses Dominionism by Rachel Tabachnick.  Chip Berlet also published a response in 2007 to a similar round of smears, denials and distortions.  




Display: